Showing posts with label tax. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tax. Show all posts

Thursday, 27 January 2011

Let It Grow, Let It Grow, Let It Grow

This week we learned that the UK economy shrank by 0.5% in the last quarter. George Osborne blamed the snow, conveniently forgetting that much of continental Europe experienced the same arctic conditions. Meanwhile Sir Richard Lambert, the outgoing head of the Confederation of British Industry, heavily criticised the government for having no economic growth strategy.

Sir Richard is right, when it comes to growth the government has some policy gimmicks but no actual strategy. Back in October last year a 'Local Growth' White Paper came out, awkwardly titled 'Realising Every Place's Potential'. Although the paper wanders erratically across planning, housing, sustainability, and region-bashing, the main message is summed up by this quote:

A further feature of earlier approaches was the belief that planning could both determine where growth should happen and stimulate that growth. This approach failed as it went against the grain of markets. Regional and other strategies stifled natural and healthy competition between places and inhibited growth as a consequence.


This makes it pretty evident that the new plan is to have no plan. The government doesn't think it needs a growth strategy. It considers the encouragement of economic growth not really any of its business; all it needs to do is destroy as much of the public sector as it can, and the economy will grow like Japanese knotweed. This is a very simplistic form of neoclassical economics, based on the lovely myth of perfect free markets. So as to ensure that the Department of Business Innovation and Skills doesn't look like a waste of space, though, a couple of policies have been announced.

Technology and Innovation centres are to be established, the first of which will allegedly open in less than two months. Next to nothing is known about what these are or what they'll do, other than the fact that they got £200 million funding in the Spending Review.

The other policy trotted out as supporting the economy is the Regional Growth Fund. This consists of £1.4 billion over 3 years, scraped together from various government departments (BIS, CLG, DEFRA, DfT, and the Treasury) for projects to 'rebalance' the economy away from the public sector. Regional Growth Fund is caught in something of a Catch-22. Public sector bodies categorically cannot apply for it. Private sector organisations can, but must ensure that they aren't breaking the rules on state aid, which try to prohibit the government from propping up certain companies at the expense of others. State aid rules are complex, hard to understand, and greatly restrict the monetary support that businesses can get. As you can imagine, this presents problems. Nonetheless, the first round of the fund (a maximum of £300 million) attracted nearly 450 bids totalling well over £2 billion.

£1.4 billion may sound like an awful lot of money, but it is trying to replace multifarious infrastructure and transport funds, on top of the £6 billion spent in the last few years alone by Regional Development Agencies. For all their faults, RDAs provided business support and economic strategy. They are being wound up at the moment and their functions centralised or simply stopped. They will not be replaced, unless you count the completely unfunded Local Enterprise Partnerships, which I am not inclined to.

How successful is the No Plan economic plan likely to be? To date the signs aren't encouraging. The government is ignoring the fact that the public sector used to spend a lot of money in the private sector. And the fact that the private sector relies on public services and infrastructure to operate. And the fact that business confidence is heavily linked to government policy. And the overall state of the world economy in relation to the UK. The economy is shrinking, and the cuts have barely started yet. VAT hadn't risen yet in the last quarter, either.

The UK is vulnerable to economic forces far beyond its control. Rises in petrol prices, which the press have been up in arms about recently. Rises in food prices, as we import so much of what we eat. Rises in cotton prices, as we import almost everything that we wear. Inflation is therefore rising whilst the economy contracts. Stagflation, as it is charmingly known, was a feature of the 1980s. Inflation now is nowhere near what it was then (4.8% compared to over 20%), but give it time. Peak Oil is on its way.

The government wants private sector growth, which would require internal demand and/or exports to pick up. Demand for products and services within the UK is unlikely to grow given high and rising unemployment, limited credit availability, and higher VAT. Faced with reduced government support for the young and elderly, people will tend to save more. The disaster that is housing policy will increase costs in that sector, too. House prices will continue to rise as new supply gets scarcer.

Demand for UK exports has grown as the value of the pound falls, but is limited by the economic troubles of our main export partners (the US, Ireland, and the rest of Europe). Moreover, our major exports are cars, weapons, and financial services. Car demand is influenced by the likelihood of unemployment and wider economic climate (alarming), credit availability (poor), and petrol costs (rising). Weapons demand is influenced by government defense spending (being cut). Financial services got us into this mess in the first place.

Despite all this negativity, I am aware that I live in one of the few places to be prospering economically. The high-tech cluster around Cambridge is one of the few bits of the UK to be a net contributor to the Treasury. But at the moment the government isn't interested in what's holding this area back; overloaded transport infrastructure, unaffordable housing, and loss of public sector co-ordination and expertise. These are market failures which cannot be fixed by the private sector.

The government has lost sight of the basic fact that you have to invest money to make more money. That's practically the only policy lever it has left, in any case. National interest rates have little influence on levels of inflation or the cost of new borrowing nowadays. Regulation and tax incentives for business aren't popular with our neoliberal coalition. Their No Plan is to spend less to make more, probably based on a hunch.

This is not to say that no economic growth equals economic doom, far from it. Growth is pointless unless it improves wellbeing, and in any event cannot carry on indefinitely. At the moment government policy seems to be shrinking the economy and reducing wellbeing, although as ever I console myself with the fact that greenhouse gas emissions fall during downturns. Ultimately the UK and the rest of the world will have to reshape our economies to operate within environmental limits. Perhaps a coalition-assisted double-dip recession might set the scene for a lower carbon, less oil-dependent economy? It's a long shot, but hope for a green revolution springs eternal. Even when government economic policy seems entirely misconceived.

Friday, 27 August 2010

Regression

Recently the Institute for Fiscal Studies has confirmed the intuitively obvious: the 2010 budget will be regressive. In other words, it will have a stronger negative impact on the poorer inhabitants of the UK.


As the IFS analysis points out, the government's budget impact assessments completely missed out £4.1 billion of the £11 billion cuts to welfare budgets, including the significant changes to Housing Benefit. Claims of a 'progressive' budget have been based on ignoring a large proportion of the policies within it. The coalition's defense of this claim continues to be based on the idea that cutting the deficit is progressive in and of itself, even if the effect of those cuts falls disproportionately on the poorest. I for one would query whether this is what 'progressive' actually means.

What particularly struck me in the IFS report is the contrast between pre-announced and budget policies. According to the IFS analysis, the coalition policies announced before the budget were geuinely progressive, taking most from the richest. These polices were basically tax-based; raising the income tax threshold, changes to national insurance, etc.

Photobucket

Compare that to the policies announced within the budget, including significant cuts to welfare budgets and an increase in the biggest regressive tax: VAT.

Photobucket

Look at that reversal. The implication is depressing but not surprising - all the nice policies were touted during the election and when the coalition was formed. Once the government was entrenched, they laid into the poor.

But is the effect regressive when all of the policies are taken into account - do they balance out?

Photobucket

In a manner of speaking they do. However, if you aren't a pensioner and don't have children, yes, the total effect of coalition tax and benefit policies is regressive. The largest proportional impact will fall on the poorest of this group. For families with children, the greatest impacts are shared between the richest and poorest. Pensioners at all income levels are effected relatively equally, as most of the changes pass them by.

Take a look at more detail of the impacts by household type.

Photobucket

The greatest negative impacts will fall on households reliant on benefits. This is consistent with the government's fuzzily-articulated aim to get people off benefits and into work. However the simplistic 'take away benefits and they'll work' approach is based on any number of fallacies, for instance that work is available, that claimants have the suitable skills for work that is available, and that it's appropriate for everyone to work. Why should a single parent work full-time? They'll just have to employ someone to care for their child(ren), which seems like a waste of money and time. Plus of course there are many with disabilities or illnesses that prevent them working.

You will note that the greatest loss of proportional income falls on households with no earners and children. I'd emphasise the word proportional; such households aren't going to have much of an income to start with. Losing 7% of it will be significant, not least in its effect on the children. It's ironic that a government claiming to be pro-family are in fact penalising people for breeding through the tax and welfare systems.

No-one gains from this budget, but to lose out least you'll need to be in a childless household of working age in the upper half of the income distribution. Which I am lucky enough to be, for the moment. (In case you're wondering where in the income distribution you are, try this tool.)

The IFS analysis is very useful, but what's more alarming is that it only models tax and benefit policies. This is reasonable, as modelling the effects of wider cuts to departmental budgets is nigh-impossible. It's important not to forget, though, that departmental budget cuts will also have a disproportionate impact on poorer households. Many don't have the option to 'go private' when public services reduce or disappear.

The 25% cuts apply to much that we take completely for granted: the police, fire service, environmental health, justice system, scientific research, flood defense, road maintenance, and public parks & nature reserves, for example. These are the kind of things people assume will be there when needed. That won't necessarily be the case.

Friday, 9 July 2010

Greenpieces

The constant stream of demagoguery coming out of the Department of Communities and Local Government has been getting me down; slogan of the day is 'Accountability to the people not the Government machine'. I therefore decided to take a look at what the Department of Energy and Climate Change was up to.


This, you might recall, is headed by Chris Huhne, a Liberal Democrat who was a candidate for the leadership of the party back in the day. The tone coming from his department, DECC, is refreshingly sensible and un-clichéd. Policy announcements so far are a mixed bag, though.

A scheme will be launched to insulate 3.5 million homes from 2012. It seems to be sensibly structured - the energy company pays the up-front cost of insulation then recoups it through the household's subsequent bills. As the household will be using less energy as a result of the insulation, they shouldn't really notice this. It would be even more effective if energy was priced more sensibly, so that the more you use the higher the unit price, but still.

The development of a new North Sea oil and gas field has been given the go ahead. They got the Conservative Energy Minister to announce this one, I notice. I'm deeply unimpressed. Talk of energy security is all very well, but the level of renewables in the UK is disgracefully low, the lowest in Europe. Prioritising North Sea oil and gas isn't going to change that.

On the other hand, the law that prevents local councils from selling renewable energy to the grid is being axed. Maybe the rule somehow made sense in 1975? Hopefully this will encourage more neighbourhood-scale renewable energy projects.

I also rather like Chris Huhne's speech to the Local Government Association. It couldn't be more different to Eric Pickles' mishmash of references to Tom Cruise films, the Cold War, and the World Cup, garnished with bureaucrat-bashing.

Sample of Huhne's speech:


But at the same time everyone here understands the over-riding urgency of tackling climate change. We have, through the Climate Change Act, a legally binding requirement to reduce the UK’s carbon emissions by 80 per cent by 2050. What we need to do now is to construct a new partnership between local and central government, which enables us to meet these goals in the fastest and most cost-effective manner possible.


Simple as that. The previous government passed the Climate Change Act, then ignored the urgency of actually doing anything to make that 80% cut.

One major environmental opportunity seems to have been missed by the coalition. I was disappointed not to see a carbon tax in the budget, which could have gradually replaced Value Added Tax (a very blunt instrument for taxing consumption). As well as raising much-needed revenue and not being as intrinsically regressive as VAT, this would have boosted the low carbon economy. Which a new report tells us is one of the few sectors of the economy growing and creating jobs during the economic doldrums. Of course, the decision to reform VAT in this way would have to come from the Treasury, which has no remit or apparent interest in the environment.

Sadly, I also suspect that a carbon tax could fall foul of the World Trade Organisation's paranoia about protectionist trade barriers. Horrifying but true, the WTO does not accept that countries should be able to set their own environmental standards.

To digress a bit, I have long thought that environmental policy is dealt with oddly in the current central government departmental structure. On the one hand, environmental impact and in particular climate change should be consistently embedded in policy across all departments - especially you, Department for Transport. On the other, policies specifically to mitigate and adapt to climate change should really be concentrated in one department, to avoid duplication. I think DECC is intended to do this, but its remit overlaps somewhat with DEFRA (the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs, which includes the Environment Agency), CLG (Communities and Local Government) and BIS (Business, Innovation and Skills).

Shorter post today as its Friday and so hot that my brain has slowed right down. Have good weekend. Coming up next week... Social housing! The Big Society! Transport policy! And so much more.