Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label politics. Show all posts

Sunday, 16 October 2011

Much Ado About Windfarms

Now that I've been made redundant, I've decided to become an armchair auditor. As an employee of a local council, I was under an obligation not to allow my personal opinions to interfere with the execution of local councillors' wishes. Such is the democratic operation of local government. This can at times be acutely frustrating, as local councillors sometimes made decisions that were very difficult to justify, and which I personally disagreed with entirely. To begin, an issue of particular interest to me: renewable energy.

South Cambridgeshire District Council covers the doughnut of attractive villages and farmland around Cambridge. It has no major population centres and a lot of picturesque and very expensive rural housing. The council has a rather two-faced approach to renewables; they love solar panels but hate wind farms.

This August their Climate Change Working Group were updated on a project to install solar panels on South Cambridgeshire Hall, the council's office in Cambourne. Which I believe is already quite an energy efficient building, as it would built quite recently. At a full council meeting in July it was also resolved to review its policies in order to encourage the installation of solar panels on listed buildings. Moreover, it is encouraging that South Cambs have kept up their local councillor Climate Change Working Group, as too many Conservative councils ditched any such thing as soon as Pickles lumbered into CLG.

However, their seemingly enlightened approach is rather undermined by Motion 90B:

It was RESOLVED that this Council supports seeking energy from renewable resources. However, applications for wind farms (2 turbines or more) cause deep concerns to our residents by nature of their size, scale and noise. This Council believes that a minimum distance of 2 kilometres between a dwelling and a turbine should be set to protect residents from disturbance and visual impact. If the applicant can prove that this is not the case a shorter distance would be considered. This will be addressed during the review of the Local Development Framework.


Notice the absence of any evidence whatsoever to support the figure of 2 km. It was apparently arbitrarily chosen to ensure that wind farm development would be considered unacceptable throughout South Cambridgeshire, as one local councillor commented that nowhere in the district is less than 2 miles (note different metric) from a dwelling. As far as I am aware, there is no map available to show what, if any, area in the district would be acceptable for wind turbine development under this edict. For reference, the government standard for a buffer zone between a wind turbine and a built-up area is 600 metres.

I was pleased to see that a member of the public responded back to this with a very sensible question:

In what way exactly would a wind turbine be judged differently to another structure of a similar size such as a manufacturing plant, water tower, crane or communications mast etc. as regards visual impact or noise? Does the motion mean that a planning application for a wind turbine might be rejected whereas an application for some other development of equivalent size, noise etc. would be considered for approval?


The councillor's answer shows how hollow the motion was - all planning applications must be considered on their merits, and refusals on the basis of, 'I just don't like wind turbines, so there' will be overturned at appeal anyway. Without evidence that a wind turbine within 2 km of a house will have a significantly detrimental effect, the whole thing is pointless posturing.

This stance would be more defensible were wind and solar capacity in the area comparable. The East of England Renewable Energy Capacity Study looked at the technical potential for renewable energy just last year. The whole report can be found here. It doesn't disaggregate to district level, but the whole of Cambridgeshire has the technical potential to produce 45,536.8 Gigawatt Hours of electricity from wind. The figure for solar is 230 GwH. South Cambridgeshire has a lot of agricultural land, ideal for wind farms, but lacks roofs to put solar panels on so the contrast in potential is likely to be even more stark.

I reserve most of my rancor for Cambridgeshire County Council, though. The County owns quite a bit of agricultural land, which it has been trying to use more effectively to bring in money. One plan was to site wind turbines on some of this land. Councillors agreed to this and a considerable amount of feasibility work was done. This was the plan:

Should all of the 4 sites proceed as outlined, based on current values the Council's income could peak at an annual rent of more than £700,000. The corresponding agricultural rent for the land lost would be less than £1,000


Plus, of course, more renewable energy and lower emissions. Local news coverage was positive and a considerable amount of consultation took place in the identified sites.

Then Councillor Nick Clarke became leader of Cambridgeshire County Council. A report went to the County Council Cabinet on the 6th September seeking to defer and basically kill the project.

It's worth reading that report, in order to confirm that there is no justification provided for the decision. Officers couldn't come up with any reasons for it in their report, but politicians did it anyway. Putting aside the environmental implications, £10,000 has already been spent on developing the project, and thus wasted if it stops. These two sections of the report (which, please note, is supposed to set out why this project isn't happening) are worth quoting:

[...] if wind farm development proceeded on all four sites over the twenty-five year life of the leases the Council’s income would peak at close to £900,000 per annum, unadjusted for rent reviews or inflation. In addition there would be direct payments by developers into local community funds of about £80,000 per annum. There are also Government proposals to allow local authorities to retain all of the business rates from wind farm sites in their area.

[...] Several tenants, with the Council’s encouragement, have been investigating the potential for small scale wind turbines on their holdings. One tenant was looking at a 100m tall but most were looking at 20m turbines which are smaller than a telecommunications mast. These capitalise on Feed in Tariffs which are expected to change in April 2012 and are considered by many to be an excellent business opportunity and are mostly receiving planning consents from District Councils.

It is also proposed that these developments are halted too. These have less of a visual impact than full size wind turbines and produce good financial returns for both the tenants and the Council. It is proposed to reimburse one tenant’s abortive costs for feasibility work which will be in the region of £5,000.


So Cambridgeshire County Council is forgoing a considerable amount of money, losing several thousand through contract breaking and abortive work, all because 'Fenland has too many wind farms already'. As the report notes, that is a purely anecdotal view; the people consulted in detail about the projects had much less negative, simplistic opinions.

You might ask why I blame this decision, which I believe is nothing short of moronic short-sighted NIMBYism, on Councillor Nick Clarke. Well, he boasts about it on his blog. His comment about putting people before profit is priceless. His inaugural speech as leader began with the phrase 'open for business'. He believes Cambridgeshire County Council should above all support and involve businesses, although apparently not those that develop wind farms. Choosing to 'put people first' in this context is a bit rich when you consider the cuts to transport, schools, and social care which merited no such consideration. Indeed, some of those cuts need not have happened if the council had, say, uncovered a large and steady source of annual income from its farmland.

Despite Councillor Clarke clearly thinking this decision was a crowd-pleaser, local media coverage was at best ambivalent. But this wasn't the end of the story, as not every County Councillor agreed with Clarke. The Enterprise, Growth, and Community Infrastructure Overview and Scrutiny Committee called in the decision. Although they didn't have the authority to overturn it, they have kicked it back to Cabinet, with a request to give reasons this time.

Quote from the minutes:

In discussion, Committee Members raised the following issues:

Wind farm development was supported and promoted by both local and national policies, and was also the policy of the Administration’s party. There was no rationality, either through evidence or policy basis, in the Cabinet decision;

Pointed out that there was a natural limit to the number of wind turbines that could be constructed. The Cabinet decision would not stop wind turbines being developed, it would merely stop the County Council and County Council tenants receiving any benefits from wind farm development;

A number of Committee Members indicated that they had been consulted prior to this Cabinet decision and had indicated that whilst some of them were not opposed to windfarms in principle, they were opposed to further wind farm development on the basis of the feedback received from their residents. It was also pointed out that the subsidies offered to develop wind farms ultimately came from tax payers’ pockets;

Suggested that the blanket ban approach needed to reconsidered, possibly to include permitting small applications below a certain height, or on a case-by-case basis;

Stressed the Council’s responsibility for its tenant farmers, and the need to reconsider this decision very carefully on the basis of evidence, and in consultation with a wide range of stakeholders; [...]


Cabinet will discuss this again on the 25th October, with a recommendation to at least lift the blanket ban on wind turbines. Cabinet meetings are open to the public, but unfortunately I have lectures that clash so can't attend. No doubt it will be enlightening.

Here is a further insight into the County Council Leader's views on wind farms:

I recognise that there are an extreme range of opinions from eco warriors who want to save the world and think that emitting less carbon in Cambridgeshire is the answer to those who just don’t like them towering over the landscape.

The trouble is if you mix in some political mantra, a Liberal Democrat opposition party who have lost their way and finding it very difficult to make any traction politically and a ruling group who want to make a positive difference for the people of Cambridgeshire a fuss is bound to happen.


(That is a direct copy and paste; I have resisted the urge to correct the punctuation and grammar.)

This should not be a party political issue. The wind turbines were proposed by a Conservative County Council administration and are now being ditched by another Conservative County Council administration. Moreover, Councillor Clarke admits that there hasn't been a proper consultation, just a few people from Fenland saying they don't like wind turbines. When this much money is at stake, that's just not good enough.

Now that I'm no longer working for a local council, I, like Nick Clarke, can 'tell it as it is'. In this case, a huge pile of bullshit. Putting people before profits, huh? People were not given the choice between a few wind turbines and local services cut being because the council ignored a £900,000/year source of income!

Properly designed wind farms, sited with local consultation, do not blight people's lives. Rolling blackouts might, and that is what we will have in 2018 if we do not invest in ALL methods of energy generation, as well as energy efficiency. There isn't a choice between wind farms and business as usual, there's a choice between wind farms and blackouts. Councillors claim that their electorates wouldn't tolerate wind farms, because they are happy to listen to small but very vocal campaign groups. Turbines aren't appropriate everywhere, but councillors wilfully ignore empirical evidence, which they seem to see as threatening. By promoting a needlessly adversarial approach to planning wind farms, councillors are preventing communities from sharing in their financial benefits. Neither is it true that everyone in Cambridgeshire hates them on principle. In Gamlingay the community are installing one of their own.

However, there are reasons to be cheerful. I comfort myself that Councillor Clarke can huff and puff against wind farms all he likes, but it'll do him little good. Although it can impede wind development on its own land, the County Council has no planning powers to prevent it elsewhere; these lie with the districts. Moreover, the anti-wind districts will find that the presumption in favour of sustainable development overturns every refusal of permission on appeal.

I've largely lost faith in the ability of local government to tackle climate change, at least in its current form. The government is wilfully ignoring the incongruence between the binding targets of the Climate Change Act and Carbon Budgets and the fact that many Conservative local councillors won't even listen to the phrase 'climate change'. There is no leadership on environmental issues to be found in most local council chambers, just apathy and cowardice disguised as 'reflecting the concerns of the electorate'. Their electorate includes young people like me, and our voices are not being heard.

This is not the case throughout Cambridgeshire, though. Cambridge City Council deserves much wider recognition for its efforts to tackle climate change. There is also a project trying to approach planning for renewable energy in a constructive, positive manner: the Cambridgeshire Renewables Infrastructure Framework. It is well worth getting involved with, as it brings individuals, businesses, and politicians together to discuss renewable energy reasonably, like adults. Such informed dialogue is badly needed to redress the balance. Local councillors are making retrogressive and short-sighted decisions; their electorates must hold them to account.

Monday, 10 October 2011

RIP Communism and Capitalism

A not-terribly-welcome aspect of my new student lifestyle is the odd night of insomnia when I simply cannot get my brain to shut up. Now that it is being encouraged to think, it doesn't necessarily want to stop just because the time happens to be, say, 4am. Luckily I don't usually have to get up the next morning. Less luckily, I do need to tomorrow.

Recently I've been thinking about free market capitalism and Marxism. Until the financial mayhem started in 2008, it was quite widely accepted that the former had triumphed and Marxism was more or less dead. Francis Fukuyama's 'End of History and the Last Man' is the best-known exponent of this. (To my shame, I haven't read it yet.) From what I can tell, Fukuyama and a host of other commentators assumed that democracy and free market capitalism were inseparable. The vast human suffering caused by the totalitarian regimes, of the USSR and China in particular, made socialism something to dread. Marx' proscriptions for the future had been fatally undermined.

Something I recently noticed about the financial shenanigans (which really need a definitive name but are unlikely to get one before they end) is that they follow Marx' view of capitalism as unstable and subject to periodic crises. Free market capitalism assumes that markets are self-correcting, yet the debt crisis in which we find ourselves was caused by the operation of free markets. Large international banks systematically understated and mismanaged risk in pursuit of profit, in the process causing an asset-price bubble that could not be sustained. Once property prices in the US began to fall and mortgage defaults increased, financial products that had been valued in the hundreds of billions of dollars became effectively worthless. This took place because unregulated free markets failed. Bankers' incentives did not encourage them to promote societal or even economic good. Information asymmetries were rampant, market power was highly concentrated, and risk was incredibly poorly managed. These problems occurred in markets that were either unregulated or extremely lightly regulated, and did not self-correct. Governments were required to step in and shore up these banks, in order that their wider roles holding deposits and lending to individuals and businesses could continue.

The bailouts have nationalised the losses made by banks, whilst their profits remain privatised. I oversimplify somewhat, but this is broadly why we now have terrifying levels of sovereign debt. Three years ago the fear was that banks had too much debt and not enough assets, now the same fear is gripping whole nations. The operation of free financial markets has destabilised entire countries. If he could, I'm sure Marx would say, "I told you so."

Now that the debt has been nationalised, it is everyone's problem. Repayment is hindered by the fact that the mind-bogglingly large sums were effectively borrowed against the value of future economic growth. That growth is no longer happening, largely as a result of the ongoing credit crunch and austerity measures designed to reduce the debt. Even the IMF admits this. The great economist Keynes took the view that recessions are caused by inadequate overall demand for goods and services; Marx also noted that capitalism periodically suffers a crisis of overproduction. Arguably, we could get growth going by stimulating demand - but this would require taking on more debt, which returns us to the starting point. In order to grow as we did before, we'd have to recreate the conditions that got us into the current doldrums. I doubt this is even possible.

Moreover, now seems to be a very good time to consider whether it is socially and environmentally desirable to stimulate demand and therefore consumption. Doesn't the Western world consume more than enough already? Is endless economic growth worth the social costs? However, very few seem to be speaking up for a Marxist revolution, for the very good reason that however accurate his assessment of current capitalism might seem, memories of communism's failure are still fresh. In my idealistic view, maybe we've gone beyond the capitalism/communism dichtomy and into a post-ideological era? Perhaps another ideology will appear, but for the moment we need to work with what we've got, two big ideas with big flaws and a wealth of information as to how they've been implemented with varying success. I think the new theory should be pragmatism. Not every country, region, or city will desire or require the same balance of free markets, regulation, public participation, taxation, etc.

There should be more choice and less absolutism. Rather than trying to shore up a clearly broken system, the EU could be considering what reforms would promote the greatest wellbeing. This is obviously easier said than done, given that institutions have their own momentum and the banks are fighting hard to survive despite having brought about their own ruin. However, I am a great believer in the power of imagining a better world. In the UK at least, this has fallen out of fashion and an apparent political and economic death spiral has made us a nation of apathetic pessimists. In a recent yougov poll, 80% of respondents said the state of Britain's economy was quite bad or very bad. Just 3% said it was good or very good. When asked how they thought the financial situation of their household would change over the next year, 62% said it would get worse and 8% said it would get better. Meanwhile, 53% said that Cameron is doing badly as Prime Minister, 54% said Milliband is doing badly as Labour leader, and 69% said Clegg is doing badly as Liberal Democrat leader. In response to a question about whether the current government is good for 'people like you', 24% said good and 53% bad. As a snapshot, that's quite a revealing survey.

In order to avoid pervasive depression, both economic and social, we need to first accept that there must be ways to make things better. I don't know what the new economies of pragmatism would look like; hopefully when I get round to reading 'Prosperity without Growth' I'll start getting an idea. What I have noticed is that The Economist chastises the Occupy Wall Street movement for a lack of ideology and lauds the economic successes of China whilst lamenting the decline of America. Lest we forget, China is far from a free democracy. The most successful free market economy of recent years is ostensibly communist; how can this be reconciled with the supposed opposition of the two ideologies? In my opinion, it no longer can be.


Soon to come: recommended reading about the credit crunch and Cambridgeshire's sometimes fraught relationship with renewable energy.

Tuesday, 19 July 2011

Stormy Weather

I have a confession to make: I can't bring myself to read the Open Public Services White Paper. Whenever I try and steel myself to pick it up, all I can think of is David Cameron tearing the social contract into tiny pieces whilst laughing maniacally. That is not a pleasant mental image.

Instead, I've read Vince Cable's 2009 book about the credit crunch, titled 'The Storm'. He wrote it in haste to try and explain the causes of the financial downturn, back when the idea of Liberal Democrats in the cabinet would have provoked disbelieving laughter. Reading it with the benefit of hindsight is very interesting.

When I borrowed this book from the library, I thought it would display the vast extent of Cable's hypocrisy once he become a government minister. I was surprised to find that some of his 2009 viewpoints accord quite closely with the coalition's stated programme. The book articulates Liberal Democrat ideology much more clearly than any of their election campaigning ever did. Cable's view is liberal in the old-fashioned sense of the word; pro-markets and anti-state in principle, but agreeing that there is need for a strong legal, regulatory, and fiscal policy basis for markets to operate within. Superficially, this agenda seems to differ from the Conservative Party (who dispute the need for a strong legal, regulatory, and fiscal policy basis, painting it all as red tape) and the Labour Party (who are more pro-state, insofar as they actually invested in public services). That's a vast oversimplification, which credits UK political parties with an ideological coherence that they don't have, but it does point to a certain sympathy between Conservative and Liberal policies. Labour at least pretended to put people before markets.

Cable clearly articulates the need for reduced UK public spending to get rid of the so-called structural deficit (a disputed term, I should add). This is now the coalition's favourite soundbite. He also emphasises the need for stronger regulation of banking. The current government have talked about this at some length; their actions have conspicuously failed to live up to their words. Remember Project Merlin and how banks continue to ignore it? Remember when banks were allowed to pay unlimited bonuses? I don't think that this was what Cable had in mind in 2009. That said, his concern was the need for multilateral reform, given the international nature of the crisis. He has been making the right noises, just without supporting action.

There is a seemingly minor but critical distinction to be made between Conservative and Liberal Democrat economic policy: in his book Cable proposes public sector cuts once stimulus has got the private sector growing; Osbourne's approach is predicated on cuts to the public sector acting as the stimulus. The former nuance has clearly been subsumed under the great coalition carnival of cuts. As I've said many times before, I doubt such sudden and deep cuts will turn out well for anyone, least of all the most vulnerable in society, the economy, and the Liberal Democrats as a political party.

'The Storm' makes it clear that unbalanced housing policy contributed significantly to the economic crisis. Cable notes that the hysterical pursuit of home ownership (influenced by political, financial, and media hype) brought about a destructive house price bubble. To avoid it happening again, a more-balanced housing market with greater proportions of social and private rented property is needed. That is definitely not what the present Housing Minister and his ministry are working towards. Interestingly, Cable suggests that a period of deflation could help to prevent a second property bubble. In 2009, this was a real possibility and deflation did actually occur (if you go by RPI). These days, inflation is above 4% and being driven by food and fuel prices rises over which the government has very little control. Both markets are dominated by cartel behaviour and global in nature, as other chapters helpfully explain.

This book is definitely at its best when looking at the global picture; the rise of China and India as economic powers, the perversity of richer countries borrowing heavily from poorer, and trends in energy and food markets are all summarised neatly. I strongly take issue with the relegation of climate change to an afterthought, though. Nonetheless, 'The Storm' is well worth reading and covers a lot of ground within 157 pages. Ultimately, though, it is fatalistic. The UK is waning as economic power, many contributory factors to the downturn remain beyond UK policy control, and even if we get our domestic policy in order recovery will remain difficult.

Cable sensibly doesn't try and predict the future; he didn't foresee the alarming prospect of Greece, Ireland, Italy, and the US threatening to default on their debts, for instance. Rather, he presents a frankly depressing vision of where things were in 2009 and the main problems that needed to be addressed. It's now 2011 and those problems remain unfixed; rebalancing the housing market, investing in education and research to strengthen the economy, economic rebalancing away from financial services, and promoting fairness by using the tax system to reduce inequality. I haven't seen evidence of the coalition government making progress with any of that, despite frequent name-checking of the latter two aims.

I still think that Vince Cable has acted hypocritically and consider his callous attitude to Southern Cross unforgivable. However all politicians (indeed all humans) are hypocrites sometimes and working in a coalition inevitably requires compromise. The astute analysis in 'The Storm' demonstrates that Cable must realise how ineffective and downright dangerous most of the policies he has to support are likely to be. As the economy stalls, the euro totters, and America seems doomed to be downgraded, I wonder if he thinks such compromise was worth it?

I did find one prediction in the concluding chapter of Cable's book: 'There is a long period of austerity ahead'. It's hard to argue with that.

Thursday, 14 April 2011

FAO Ed Milliband

An especially dispiriting feature of current public life is the combination of low government approval ratings and a lack of credible alternate narrative from the opposition. Labour's dossier on the NHS reforms might be a sign of greater feistiness, but I've yet to notice any real headway on economic matters. The government's economic messages are dominating the media. Their basic framework seems to be:



Labour is having trouble countering this story, which makes a certain amount of simplistic sense when repeated often enough with firm hand gestures. Nothing is that simple, however, and the government's story is based on ideology and fallacy. Labour, here is a suggested economic story that you could be telling.

Let us go back to the very basics. An economy is a system for allocating resources. Economies came into being as a method for humans to allocate resources more effectively. They do not exist in order to grow endlessly. An economy that does not improve the wellbeing of those who participate in it is a failure, whether or not it is growing according to measures of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). An economy that inflates on paper but has no impact on quality of life is wasting resources.

It is becoming increasingly clear that increases in national GDP have little or no impact on wellbeing in developed countries. Indeed, a rash of recent books (I recommend Happiness by Richard Layard) point out that measured wellbeing has flatlined in recent decades. The government has even acknowledged this, but without accepting that they might need to do something about it. Politicians are elected with a responsibility to improve the wellbeing of their electorate. The economy is not the electorate, and a narrow focus on promoting economic growth is an abrogation of responsibility.

When you approach the government narrative from that perspective, it looks much less credible.

"The country is dangerously in debt." Government debt has previously been at higher levels and the country has survived . What makes the current situation specifically worse is that credit ratings agencies, financial markets, and the International Monetary Fund say it is worse. All three have strongly vested interests in taking that view. Credit ratings agencies make assessments of how well national governments and companies can repay debt, but are not held accountable for the accuracy or impact of their assessments. They are profit-seeking companies, not independent agencies. Credit ratings agencies are in fact part of the financial markets that make their profits from betting on whether debt can be repaid. The IMF is an organisation driven by flawed free-market ideology. Reducing public spending is its policy prescription for any economic downturn, an approach which contributed disastrously to the 1997 Asian financial crisis.

"Labour spent too much. The debt is their fault." The last government spent a lot of money bailing out the banks. I don't know whether that was the right decision, but it should at least be seen in a wider context. Most European countries were also bailing out their banks in late 2008, as was America. Blaming the Labour government specifically is ridiculous, as this was the same approach taken, for good or ill, by the rest of the Western world. Until the bailouts, UK debt levels were stable.

"Too much was spent on public services and, in particular, welfare. We can't afford to spend so much on these things." This is manifestly ideological. There is no specific level of public spending that an economy can afford. Different countries choose to tax and spend to different degrees, according to political persuasion. To say that basic public services cannot be afforded presupposes that the economy is more important than people's wellbeing. If the economy is growing but wellbeing decreasing, the government has the wrong priorities and policies. Whilst it isn't inevitable that lowering public spending will reduce wellbeing, in the case of the coalition's cuts it seems inevitable. Security is an immensely important aspect of wellbeing. Reducing the welfare safety net, the quality of healthcare, the accessibility of education, the affordability of public transport, and the availability of the emergency service, whilst unemployment rises and prices inflate; that's a recipe for insecurity and anxiety.

"Therefore public spending must be cut as fast as possible." The speed at which cuts take place is likewise ideological. Spending time carefully considering the evidence and evaluating the risks of withdrawing and reducing public services assumes you value them in the first place. The government simply does not. Their debt deadline is entirely arbitrary; there will not be bailiffs banging on the door of the Treasury if we still have a deficit in 2015.

"Cutting spending will, in and of itself, provide a stimulus to economic growth." This is a delusion. Spending cuts have only just started and the economy is already contracting, with growth forecasts repeatedly cut. Even if economic growth was an aim worth pursuing in itself, rapidly cutting public spending would not make it happen.

The government is cutting public spending quickly, with no understanding or interest in how it will hurt the vulnerable. Not only is this damaging the wellbeing of millions, it is not even going to achieve the stated aim. These are the messages that Labour should be emphasising more clearly. When the challenge comes back, "But you didn't have a plan to deal with the deficit!", the obvious response is that rebuilding and reforming the economy in order to avoid a repeat of this kind of banking collapse takes time and evidence. A considered approach is clearly preferable to rushing into dramatic contraction of the whole public sector, with only discredited ideology to support you. The coalition government threw together an emergency budget in less than a month, cutting millions without considering the unintended consequences. Labour need to say clearly what this means: that the government does not care how the cuts blight people's lives. Labour should position itself as the party that puts people before economic ideology, whereas the government does the opposite. Perhaps they might even consider supporting the claim with some policies.

I should mention that I've never actually voted for Labour in a general election. It isn't that I'm a staunch Millibandit (or whatever you'd call it), I just yearn for a strong opposition in Westminster. Hopefully Labour are currently formulating an approach that will lift the level of debate above the present no-cuts-versus-all-the-cuts doldrums. I enjoyed the friendly atmosphere whilst marching for the alternative on March 26th, but demonstrations like that aren't nearly enough. The government's economic policies must be challenged more strongly by politicians. The coalition's narrative is not just slightly misleading, it is entirely wrong. It's time that the opposition stood up and said that.

If they already have and the media has failed to inform me of the fact, please be so kind as to provide a link.

Thursday, 27 January 2011

Let It Grow, Let It Grow, Let It Grow

This week we learned that the UK economy shrank by 0.5% in the last quarter. George Osborne blamed the snow, conveniently forgetting that much of continental Europe experienced the same arctic conditions. Meanwhile Sir Richard Lambert, the outgoing head of the Confederation of British Industry, heavily criticised the government for having no economic growth strategy.

Sir Richard is right, when it comes to growth the government has some policy gimmicks but no actual strategy. Back in October last year a 'Local Growth' White Paper came out, awkwardly titled 'Realising Every Place's Potential'. Although the paper wanders erratically across planning, housing, sustainability, and region-bashing, the main message is summed up by this quote:

A further feature of earlier approaches was the belief that planning could both determine where growth should happen and stimulate that growth. This approach failed as it went against the grain of markets. Regional and other strategies stifled natural and healthy competition between places and inhibited growth as a consequence.


This makes it pretty evident that the new plan is to have no plan. The government doesn't think it needs a growth strategy. It considers the encouragement of economic growth not really any of its business; all it needs to do is destroy as much of the public sector as it can, and the economy will grow like Japanese knotweed. This is a very simplistic form of neoclassical economics, based on the lovely myth of perfect free markets. So as to ensure that the Department of Business Innovation and Skills doesn't look like a waste of space, though, a couple of policies have been announced.

Technology and Innovation centres are to be established, the first of which will allegedly open in less than two months. Next to nothing is known about what these are or what they'll do, other than the fact that they got £200 million funding in the Spending Review.

The other policy trotted out as supporting the economy is the Regional Growth Fund. This consists of £1.4 billion over 3 years, scraped together from various government departments (BIS, CLG, DEFRA, DfT, and the Treasury) for projects to 'rebalance' the economy away from the public sector. Regional Growth Fund is caught in something of a Catch-22. Public sector bodies categorically cannot apply for it. Private sector organisations can, but must ensure that they aren't breaking the rules on state aid, which try to prohibit the government from propping up certain companies at the expense of others. State aid rules are complex, hard to understand, and greatly restrict the monetary support that businesses can get. As you can imagine, this presents problems. Nonetheless, the first round of the fund (a maximum of £300 million) attracted nearly 450 bids totalling well over £2 billion.

£1.4 billion may sound like an awful lot of money, but it is trying to replace multifarious infrastructure and transport funds, on top of the £6 billion spent in the last few years alone by Regional Development Agencies. For all their faults, RDAs provided business support and economic strategy. They are being wound up at the moment and their functions centralised or simply stopped. They will not be replaced, unless you count the completely unfunded Local Enterprise Partnerships, which I am not inclined to.

How successful is the No Plan economic plan likely to be? To date the signs aren't encouraging. The government is ignoring the fact that the public sector used to spend a lot of money in the private sector. And the fact that the private sector relies on public services and infrastructure to operate. And the fact that business confidence is heavily linked to government policy. And the overall state of the world economy in relation to the UK. The economy is shrinking, and the cuts have barely started yet. VAT hadn't risen yet in the last quarter, either.

The UK is vulnerable to economic forces far beyond its control. Rises in petrol prices, which the press have been up in arms about recently. Rises in food prices, as we import so much of what we eat. Rises in cotton prices, as we import almost everything that we wear. Inflation is therefore rising whilst the economy contracts. Stagflation, as it is charmingly known, was a feature of the 1980s. Inflation now is nowhere near what it was then (4.8% compared to over 20%), but give it time. Peak Oil is on its way.

The government wants private sector growth, which would require internal demand and/or exports to pick up. Demand for products and services within the UK is unlikely to grow given high and rising unemployment, limited credit availability, and higher VAT. Faced with reduced government support for the young and elderly, people will tend to save more. The disaster that is housing policy will increase costs in that sector, too. House prices will continue to rise as new supply gets scarcer.

Demand for UK exports has grown as the value of the pound falls, but is limited by the economic troubles of our main export partners (the US, Ireland, and the rest of Europe). Moreover, our major exports are cars, weapons, and financial services. Car demand is influenced by the likelihood of unemployment and wider economic climate (alarming), credit availability (poor), and petrol costs (rising). Weapons demand is influenced by government defense spending (being cut). Financial services got us into this mess in the first place.

Despite all this negativity, I am aware that I live in one of the few places to be prospering economically. The high-tech cluster around Cambridge is one of the few bits of the UK to be a net contributor to the Treasury. But at the moment the government isn't interested in what's holding this area back; overloaded transport infrastructure, unaffordable housing, and loss of public sector co-ordination and expertise. These are market failures which cannot be fixed by the private sector.

The government has lost sight of the basic fact that you have to invest money to make more money. That's practically the only policy lever it has left, in any case. National interest rates have little influence on levels of inflation or the cost of new borrowing nowadays. Regulation and tax incentives for business aren't popular with our neoliberal coalition. Their No Plan is to spend less to make more, probably based on a hunch.

This is not to say that no economic growth equals economic doom, far from it. Growth is pointless unless it improves wellbeing, and in any event cannot carry on indefinitely. At the moment government policy seems to be shrinking the economy and reducing wellbeing, although as ever I console myself with the fact that greenhouse gas emissions fall during downturns. Ultimately the UK and the rest of the world will have to reshape our economies to operate within environmental limits. Perhaps a coalition-assisted double-dip recession might set the scene for a lower carbon, less oil-dependent economy? It's a long shot, but hope for a green revolution springs eternal. Even when government economic policy seems entirely misconceived.

Wednesday, 12 January 2011

Happy New Year

It's 2011. The sky is grey, it's raining, and Cambridgeshire County Council are making 450 people redundant this year. Unions expect a further 450 or so jobs to go in subsequent years.

The latest survey of local councils, police authorities, fire authorities, and national park bodies suggests that 102,000 jobs will be lost in total. What's striking about this figure is that it covers the 131 of about 500 such organisations. The other 369 organisations have yet to announce their job cuts. Every local authority will be making people redundant. All councils, police, and fire services are facing unprecedented budget reductions. If anyone still thinks that such cuts and job losses will have no effect on services, they must be entirely deluded.

A local council chief executive has even dared to say what every single local government employee is thinking:

You've got this clown of a secretary of state saying that in well-run councils, the public won't notice any difference, I mean what planet is this guy on?

Public servants aren't supposed to be angry, but you look at this and it's unfair.

It's the big lie tactic that if you tell a big enough lie, and say it often enough, then people will believe it.


Like every other public servant, I am supposed to be impartial. But how can anyone with a conscience remain supportive of government policy when its this destructive? Like every other local authority, Cambridgeshire County Council needs to make savings from all services. That includes protection of vulnerable children, care for elderly and disabled adults, and primary and secondary education. Kids and vulnerable adults will pay for mistakes made by bankers. The same bankers whose bonuses will not be limited by the government.

The most important purpose of the public sector is to protect the people who need it. When the government prioritises an ideological war on public spending above essential health, education, emergency, and social services, it is fundamentally failing to do its job. Public servants picked up on this last year. In 2011 I think the wider population are going to realise what austerity means, and they will get angry too.

Tuesday, 7 September 2010

I Used to Care But Now Things Have Changed

This post has a soundtrack from the wonderful Mr. Bob Dylan: Things Have Changed.


I've recently been giving some thought to how my views on cutting the budget deficit have changed over the past year.

In 2009 my bugbear was the Labour government's 'deficit-what-deficit?' policy. At the time, it seemed entirely irresponsible to ignore the budget cuts and tax rises that would clearly need to happen. Moreover, both opposition parties seemed to be colluding to cover this up. Prior to and during the election this year, none of the three parties put forward proposals for how exactly they would tackle the deficit. All of them said that it would be tackled, then waved away the details of how. The principle point of argument then turned out into when the deficit should be dealt with.

During this pre-election period, I was enthusiastically pro-cuts, as well as pro-restructuring taxation. During the time I've worked in the public sector, I've witnessed a lot of what felt like wasteful and pointless expenditure of time and resources. I found it deeply frustrating at times that public sector structures evolve so slowly, and are never quite suitable for the current challenge. So I thought that tackling the deficit could prove to be a great opportunity to restructure institutions in order to tackle climate change, inequality and social deprivation. To identify wasteful areas of spending and duplication, to reconnect public institutions with the public they serve, and to demonstrate that a low carbon future is actually cheaper than business as usual. What I hoped for was a long-term plan for reducing public spending whilst kick-starting a low carbon economy.

Naturally, many of the phrases I've used in the above paragraph were also featured in the manifestos of all three political parties. The coalition document probably included most of them too. But I've become a lot more cynical in the past few months, and the government's deficit reuction plans are not what I had in mind.

The most critical difference is that I thought the public sector should be restructured in a considered way, with a view to the long term. Specifically, with a view to 2050, when we will be emitting 80% less carbon dioxide. So says the Climate Change Act. In contrast, the coalition have made a point of doing everything very fast. They threw together an emergency budget, abolished all manner of institutions, and proposed almighty upheavals of every government department in their first month of government. In fact, they claimed proudly to be turning the entire concept of government upside down.

What has changed my view on cuts is that the public sector and population at large have been entirely absent from this decision making. I don't call a couple of websites inviting bright ideas sufficient consultation for turning government upside down. Indeed, even the usual impact assessments seem to have been skipped for many changes. Until October's spending review, it won't be clear exactly how much pain each agency, scheme, and fund will carry over the next few years. This uncertainty and feeling of utter helplessness results in a public sector full of very jumpy, disillusioned employees with a penchant for black humour.

I am no longer the enthusiast that I was because the suddenness and depth of the coalition's cuts scare me. I simply don't see how they can possibly help the economy to recover. The government's message seems to be that reducing the deficit, whatever the effect on the public sector, will miraculously fix the weak economy.

This ignores basic economic theory - government spending is part of GDP. Reduce spending and GDP falls. Cut jobs and unemployment rises. There is no automatic rebalancing whereby the private sector grows as the public sector shrinks; the two are interdependent. To illustrate, ministers often rail about the public sector wasting money on consultants. Well if that money wasn't wasted, those private sector consultants wouldn't have jobs. Wasteful it may be, but it's also a job subsidy. Likewise, infrastructure investment required private sector firms to actually build the bridges, roads, and railways, which they make a tidy profit on. Public sector support for education and research is absolutely vital to the private sector; if the UK doesn't offer the skills and innovation companies need, they will go elsewhere.

Reducing the size of the public sector will therefore reduce the size of the private sector, at least initially. A significant, possibly record-breaking, rise in unemployment next year looks inevitable. There's nothing like high unemployment to knock confidence amongst banks (mortgage arrears!), retailers (saving not spending!), and markets (recession!). Rising unemployment also has huge social impacts, reduces tax revenues, and, without significant intervention, perpetuates itself to the next generation.

In 2009 I thought that sensible cuts could bring about economic recovery, and feared that the government would just ignore the deficit and lumber on regardless. In 2010, I no longer have to worry about the deficit being ignored, quite the opposite. Perhaps this is a case of be careful what you wish for? The problem is that the cuts we're getting look like they will damage both the economy and our ability to tackle climate change and social problems.

Ironically, over the past year not that much has changed in relation to my job. In 2009 I didn't think that it would last beyond 2011. Now I'm nearly certain that it won't. Which brings me neatly to an elegantly written new blog that I found through Society Guardian, documenting how it feels to be a redundant public servant. The author writes from a much more level-headed perspective than me, as befits someone with 20 years in the public sector to my 4. I recommend that you take a look.

Wednesday, 28 July 2010

Ill Fares The Land

In George Orwell's 1984, Winston is given a book:

'[It] fascinated him, or more exactly it reassured him. In a sense it told him nothing that was new, but that was part of the attraction. It said what he would have said, if it had been possible for him to set his scattered thoughts in order. It was the product of a mind similar to his own, but enormously more powerful, more systematic, less fear-ridden. The best books, he perceived, are those that tell you what you know already.'


Last night I finished reading exactly such a book, Ill Fares The Land by Tony Judt. It challenges the largely unspoken assumptions that have dominated economic policy in the Western world since the 1980s. The book brought some thoughts that have been nagging at me into focus. So rather than getting a reasonable amount of sleep last night, I wrote a political diatribe. It isn't polished or structured, but it's a sincere response to that remarkable book.


Why have we stopped imagining any alternative to free market capitalism? This is a question I've long wondered about, now re-awoken in my head. The simplistic communism/unfettered free-market capitalism diochotomy is frankly stupid. Surely humanity can manage more sophisticated thinking? Why haven't the interdependencies between markets and governments been acknowledged and studied?

How did the economic growth become an end in itself rather than a means to an end?

Have we forgotten the original purpose of government and the public sector?

Why are we as a society willing to tolerate huge and growing inequalities? High unemployment? Social exclusion and poverty? All in the name of economic growth and the ubiquitous totem of efficiency.

Why do we now value efficiency above everything else, without even knowing what it means?

Why can't the wealthiest countries in the world afford basic public services any more?

The coalition government are trying to dismantle the state, whilst telling us that we don't need it. If that is indeed the case, why has it persisted in being useful for hundreds of years? Why did our estimation of its value suddenly plummet in the 1980s?

Where has our faith in markets come from? Unregulated markets are as unsuccessful as over-regulated ones, just in a different way. Monopolistic exploitation vs so-called inefficiency - which do you prefer?

Economics has become akin to a religious mystery, with a priesthood of bankers telling us its too complex for us to understand or be included in. That's a lie. The basis of economics, the laws of supply and demand and the concept of markets, are very simple. Deceptively so, as they fail to reflect the ways that human beings, and the institutions and markets in which they interact, actually behave. I remember being taught about models of long term economic growth about six years ago and realising, with some amazement, that none of them stood up to scrutiny. They all made assumptions that are utterly ridiculous - infinite capital, for example. Yet we continue to put our faith in these models, because no-one has stood up and said, 'BUT THAT'S JUST NOT TRUE!' No-one does that because they're afraid of being told, 'Oh, you just aren't clever enough to understand.' (I tried to discredit these models in an undergraduate essay, but that was never going to shake the world to its foundations.)

The goal of a government should not be to promote economic growth above all else. Governments exist to protect their citizens, to create an environment of fairness, justice and equity for all. We are not dismissive of governments because these concepts are no longer relevant in the twenty-first century, but because governments appear to have lost faith in them. All debates on fairness are framed in purely economic terms, as if the only freedom anyone needs is the ability to make as much money as they can.

Public sector workers are increasingly being demonised as meddling, obstructive bureaucrats. At times I have felt guilty that I am paid by the public purse, because my job isn't absolutely essential to the continued functioning of the UK. Now I think, why the hell should I apologise? I do my job to make the world a better place, insofar as I can. The aim of it is to improve life in Cambridgeshire, by planning for the population's future needs now. Why are workers in the private sector being painted as morally superior, for working merely to enrich themselves and the shareholders in their companies? What is wasteful about working to improve the environment and people's lives? How did we as a society get to the point where a public servant is a drain on the country rather than an asset to it?

Why does this feel like a radical thing to question? Because at the moment it is. We have a cabinet minister who fears 'cigar chomping commies', a Prime Minister who thinks the state should retract and let mythical communities provide their own public services. The NHS and education systems are about to be dismantled. Government support in every single sector of society that you can imagine is being scaled back or withdrawn. The overriding goal of this government is to cut public spending, whatever the human cost.

At the moment, I think people feel a mixture of three emotions about this:

  1. Ignorance ('none of this will effect me')

  2. Vague satisfaction ('ha, those wasteful bureaucrats deserve a bit of a shock; after the recession we've had in the private sector, it's their turn to feel some pain')

  3. Vague fear & unsettlement ('there are a lot of changes happening suddenly, I don't remember voting for this')


To 1, oh yes it will.

To 2, when the private sector suffers, private sector employees feel it. When the public sector suffers, everyone feels it. Because everyone uses public services, however much they unknowingly take them for granted.

To 3, now you're actually thinking.

I refuse to apologise for so-called bureaucratic wastefulness any longer. Why is it so much more reprehensible for the public sector to allegedly waste a little than the private sector to waste a lot? Which is better value to society - thousands of people employed doing so-called 'bureaucratic non-jobs' or a vast handout to a bank? The former do not meet economic definitions of efficiency, and their value cannot necessarily be quantified. But that does not mean that they're valueless and less justifiable than bailing out a huge private bank, which will then confirm its commitment to inequality by paying billions in bonuses whilst refusing to lend to small businesses.

The public sector has been on the defensive for thirty years, since it became the norm to measure success in purely economic terms. That is a stupid, wrong-headed way to assess whether services like a rail network, health centre, or environmental protection agency are operating well. We must learn to measure beyond money. There are many things too important to try and quantify so simplistically; health, education, and the environment, for example.

I do not think that the public sector is perfect and the private sector evil, just because I refute the notion that the public sector is always wrong. We need a more intelligent and nuanced view of both sectors, and of their interdependence.

Tony Judt ends with an entreaty that if you agree with him that something has gone very wrong with how we are governed, do something about it. He doesn't specify what, because that's a much harder question. Nonetheless, I feel galvanised and somehow vindicated. It's very frustrating to disagree with so many government policies, dissecting each into tiny pieces so as to describe how they are goes wrong. All current policies start from flawed economic and political assumptions, assumptions that have become so widely accepted since the 1980s that we have almost forgotten how to contradict them. We criticise high train fares, fear the threat of unemployment, feel vaguely guilty about our inefficiencies, and aspire vaguely to wealth as it is is supposed to make us happy. So little in culture or media contradicts this.

My generation needs to read Ill Fares The Land, it's well worth losing sleep over. We need to be reminded that a better world is possible, and that better is not a synonym for richer.

There is no profit in trying to build utopia. Attempting to make the world better for people requires thinking beyond market transactions, it demands imagination of a kind that modern life seems to suppress. The UK is at a turning point, with an anti-government government telling us to go away and govern ourselves. Perhaps this is a chance for our imaginations to awaken, for us to recognise what we really want from the state, and most importantly for us to challenge the notion that human beings exist to produce products and services more efficiently. That is what our economy and our political system are based on.

Does anyone really believe that to be true? Do you?