Showing posts with label youth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label youth. Show all posts

Tuesday, 15 November 2011

Reading List

A while back I read an excellent book on the financial crisis: Freefall by Joseph Stiglitz. Although it provides a clear and compelling explanation of how the US housing bubble formed, infected banks around the world, and nearly brought then all down, my overriding impression was that Stiglitz was barely restraining himself from just writing, 'YOU BASTARDS, LOOK AT WHAT YOU'VE DONE! LOOK AT WHAT YOU'RE STILL DOING! BASTARDS, BASTARDS, BASTARDS!' I might be projecting slightly there, but Stiglitz is clearly very unhappy about the abject failure of banks to behave responsibly, their apparent inability to admit to any failure whatsoever, and their craven lobbying for their losses to be born by governments. As we all should be, and books like this are very important.

Much of the other literature on the financial crisis that I've read has been too measured. For instance, Gillian Tett's Fool's Gold provides the best explanation I've come across for the toxic financial products that banks invented, with a narrative concerning the team at JPMorgan who came up with many of them. Tett clearly has to tread a fine line - she interviewed these people for her book and presents them as three dimensional characters, so won't fully condemn their behaviour. Nonetheless, the bigger picture cannot be ignored. What should have been technical innovations of interest only to industry specialists spread throughout the financial system like a virus and precipitated the credit crunch, the worst recession for 80 years, and a sudden ballooning of government debts. Stiglitz spells this out clearly, Tett does not.

(As an aside, one of the many ironies of the crisis is that had the US not sold so many of these financial products abroad, as the financial markets are so globalised, their impact would have been much worse in America but the rest of the world's banks would have been relatively unscathed. Thanks for the exports, yanks.)

Neither book addresses the current government debt disaster (crisis seems too gentle a word), as they were both published two years ago. Back then we were worried that banks would not be able to pay their debts. Now it is governments that look doubtful, as the debt burden has been nationalised. The final chapter of this one hasn't even begun yet, but I distinctly doubt it will be pretty.

Meanwhile, my fellow students and I are still spammed by leaflets and emails suggesting we attend recruitment events for investment banks. Naively I assumed that this recruitment hard sell had waned in the past few years; apparently not. These adverts are always very innocuously worded, emphasising words like 'challenge'. It really angers me that quite a few students might swallow this stuff and equate working in The City with succeeding in life. This is what I want to say to them:

You do not have to be a banker.

The careers service assumes that you want to get a job in The City. The big banks are trying to court you with swanky events, free pens, and high starting salaries. They are trying to create an aura of prestige around themselves. But be absolutely clear about what their business is - transferring wealth from the poorly-off to the already wealthy. They aren't creating anything that wasn't already there, just moving worth around and exaggerating the value of investments.

Theirs is an industry that recently experienced systemic, catastrophic failure, and required gigantic bailouts from the public sector. The banks lobbied against any government regulation then systematically failed to manage risk. They have undermined the fundamentals on which the world economy is based and left the mess for others to clear up. Unemployment is high and growing, first world governments are threatening to default on their debt, and there is no way back to business as usual.

Is this really the industry you want to work for? Do you genuinely think your intelligence and skills are best used to make wealth inequalities worse? And the backlash against bankers has hardly begun - do you honestly want to be on the wrong side of it?

It may seem at the moment like banking is the most obvious career option, simply because banking firms make the loudest play for your attention. There are many other things you could do. In my third year as an undergraduate I shared a house with six other women. The seven of us are all ambitious, intelligent, and driven, but not one of us got a job primarily motivated by profit. One teaches English as a second language, one monitors dangerous diseases at the Health Protection Agency. Another is an army officer, yet another works as a civil servant in the Treasury. Amongst out number you will also find a doctor and a Teaching Assistant who writes novels on the side. I myself have worked in Local Government, helping to plan new communities for the past three years. Can you honestly tell me that our various talents and abilities would all be better spent trading collateralised debt obligations?

The world is facing massive challenges - climate change, terrible inequalities between and within states, demographic shifts, not to mention rebuilding our economies to promote well-being rather than endless, impossible growth. Those are real challenges worth confronting, rather than pursuing the pseudo-achievement of pushing up refinancing fees. There are a myriad of career options out there; don't waste your brain and your life on banking.

If you're still tempted, at least go in with open eyes. Read Freefall and Fool's Gold, then try and tell me that Goldman Sachs et al deserve the benefit of the doubt.


Personally, my next career step is to apply for a PhD, as I find myself very much enjoying the life of research. I doubt there will be much of any funding around, but I intend to have a damn good look.

Tuesday, 9 August 2011

The More I Read The Less I Know

England has suddenly exploded with rioting. It's happening as I type this. One of my friends has been evacuated from her flat because a police station down the road was petrol-bombed. It is grotesque and terrifying that law and order can break down so quickly and comprehensively, that so many people suddenly resort to violence and looting with seeming impunity. It is genuinely difficult to comprehend the seriousness of what is happening. The last riots of any comparable scale happened before I was born.

I've been following the media and twitter coverage closely. The Guardian, Telegraph, and BBC have impressively thorough 24 hour feeds, delivering a stream of images and anecdotes to illustrate the mayhem. The sheer shock and horror at rampant arson, vandalism, and theft naturally breeds an urge to understand why. Why is this happening? How has it escalated so dramatically? And why now?

The impression I've got in the last few days is that it is simply impossible to answer those questions at the moment, and attempts to do so are largely interesting for what they reveal about the commentator. As ever, the wider the generalisation, the more likely confirmation bias is to be at work. Compare for yourself:

Two utterly different views from the Telegraph: Philip Johnston and Mary Riddell.

Camila Batmanghelidjh in the Independent

Richard Littlejohn in The Mail

Nina Power in The Guardian.

For international flavour, Doug Saunders in the Canadian Globe and Mail

From bloggers: Penny Red, Winston Smith, The New Economics Foundation, and Rosamicula on livejournal.

The main point of difference between commentators seems to be the allocation of responsibility; society vs individual and state vs market. Despite this it has surprised me to what extent there is overlap, despite variations in tone. Bringing party politics or even distinctions between right- and left-wing into consideration of the riots seems somewhat artificial, and has happened in the press less than it could have done. The violence is more sudden and uncontrollable than anyone expected, right or left wing, and it is therefore difficult to explain with standard right vs left political narratives. There seems to be more use of such narratives on Twitter, probably due to its inherent difficulties with complexity. Nuance cannot adequately be conveyed or statements properly qualified within 140 characters.

Speculation is rife as there is simply very little data at the moment. We don't know who the rioters are; images in the news suggest predominantly poor teenagers, but there are also reports of adults. We don't know how many there are. We don't know the full extent of what they've done and may still do. Most importantly, we don't know their pretexts for embarking on this illegal, destructive, dangerous course of action. Factors that have been suggested include: rising inequality, weakness in the penal system, amoral individualism, family breakdown, lack of trust in the police, endemic unemployment, consumerist popular culture, drugs, failures of the education system, lack of respect for authority figures, cuts such as the abolition of Education Maintenance Allowance, absence of aspirations, and violent video games. All of these and more could apply; the foolish thing at this point would be to rule anything out for ideological reasons.

It would of course be very convenient for my personal opinions if I could blame the riots solely on the coalition government's cuts and wider economy-centric, rather than people-centric, policy making. But there isn't enough evidence to support or undermine that view. I believe that those two factors are significant, however I could be wrong. For something this big and bad to happen, there cannot be a single simple explanation. Once the police have re-established order and the dust has settled, it should become clearer why the riots occurred, and then we face the more difficult task of doing something about it. The mindset and circumstances that led people to riot will need to be tackled somehow, otherwise there is bound to be more violence to come.

Friday, 10 December 2010

The Way We Live Now

When I started this blog in July, it seemed to me that those working outside the public sector hadn't yet realised that there were massive changes ahead. To be fair, I had only a hazy idea myself, but enough to feel alarmed at the prospect. There has definitely been a shift in recent weeks. I've noticed that conversations with colleagues, family, friends, in fact just about anyone, circle inexorably back to the telling phrase, 'We live in interesting times.' Everyone is saying this, and the required response is to nod sagely and murmur, 'Interesting times indeed.' This sequence confirms that you, like the other party in the conversation, are an observer of dramatic events beyond your control.

The next step, of course, is to shift from observer to participant, as the protesting students have done. I subscribe to the view that the protests are about a lot more than tuition fees. Young people are protesting now because they feel they have nothing to lose by doing so, because they feel that their opportunities are being taken away. Whatever the actual impacts of the complex new tuition fees scheme (which might be more progressive than the current system, I haven't examined it in sufficient detail to say), putting a price of £9,000 a year on a degree is an ideological statement. Whereas previous governments emphasised the value of higher education to society, the coalition is framing it as an asset to the individual, one that needs to be purchased. I don't think the government understand how much of a shift in the social contract this is, nor how hypocritical it looks in light of their fairness and social mobility rhetoric.

When I was a student, the times weren't especially interesting. I graduated prior to the introduction of top-up fees. During my degree there was a general election in which the incumbent Labour government faced no serious threat, and the economy remained boringly stable throughout. Despite this, as students do, I spent long hours sitting round a kitchen table putting the world to rights with my friends. There is a vast gap between those debates and the protests now. They are manifestations of the same student political awareness, altered by the seismic economic and political changes of the intervening years. The twentisomethings of my generation graduated with plenty of debt (£10-£25,000 for the most part), but we expected to and for the most part did find jobs. Our future looked stable.

It isn't anymore. Many of my university friends now work in the public sector; in education, the army, Whitehall, the NHS, quangos, or local government. I don't think any of us can say with confidence that our jobs aren't to some extent at risk. My whole team is now officially at risk of redundancy, although we've yet to receive the letter confirming this. Most importantly, we have little reason to believe that there will be other jobs available if/when we are kicked out of the public sector. In the mixture of positive and negative economic news, it remains a fact that there are already more job-seekers than there are vacancies in the UK. Unlike our older colleagues of many years experience, we twentisomethings will get minimal redundancy payouts, certainly not enough to start our own business or keep us off Job Seeker's Allowance. We have been basically priced out of the housing market, so are unlikely to have either the asset of a house or the burden of a mortgage.

Where does this leave us? Certainly in a better position than teenagers and students, which is why we've yet to take to the streets. In my opinion, it leaves us as prime brain drain material. I wonder if my generation will take a look at the lack of jobs, collapsing public services, and disgust with politics in the UK, and decide to go elsewhere? Being stuck in renting makes us mobile and our degrees apparently now command a great premium. Although many other countries are experiencing austerity, we are the only one to be saddled with the sickening spectacle of David Cameron and Nick Clegg telling us that we are all in this together. For those with languages, France and Germany beckon. For others, Australia is having an economic boom (unsustainably based on exporting raw materials to China, admittedly), or what about New Zealand, Canada, and the less Tea Party-ridden parts of America. In fact, there's a whole world out there, and it's looking increasingly appealing.

I can't understand why the government seems amazed that instability causes protest. Perhaps they're just feigning surprise that young people complain when their certainties and security are suddenly stripped away. During 'interesting times' you can either get involved or watch from a safe distance. A lot of people my age will soon be faced with that decision.


Meanwhile, Cambridgeshire County Council has announced that its budget is being cut by £160 million over the next five years. £50 million must be saved next year, and that front-loading will have an especially significant impact. An estimated 450 jobs will go. Suffolk-esque kamikaze outsourcing does not appear to be the preferred option, encouragingly. A consultation on where the cuts should be made can be found here.

Edited To Add: Having had a go at the consultation survey, I'd urge everyone who lives in the county to do the same. It's eye-opening - whatever distribution of cuts is decided, it's clear that support for the most vulnerable people (the elderly and at-risk children) will be cut. In addition, up to 19 libraries could be closed and up to 80 bus routes stopped.

Thursday, 11 November 2010

Winter discontent

In addition to the major policy statements coming out on a weekly basis, promising radical change to avert a doomed debt-spiral, there are indications of the age of austerity closer to home.

Last week a pair of Jehovah's Witnesses handed me a leaflet about how Jesus can help you through unemployment. It contained an incongruous mixture of budgeting tips and bible quotes. My bank has ceased the barrage of letters begging me to take out a loan. I applaud the saving of paper, but assume that 25 year olds don't get loans anymore. My union dues have suddenly gone up. A recent update email from my alma mater dwelt at length on its financial position, relegating exam results and sports teams to short mentions at the end.

Students are protesting, rioting even, out of anger at the betrayal by the government of all that they held certain. I can well understand their rage. If tuition fees had been anything like £9,000 when I was a student, I would have been priced out of the better universities. Including the one I attended.

Conversations at work increasingly focus on what we plan to do after March 31st next year, when the funding for our jobs evaporates. We've been told that the redundancy 'consultation process' takes six months, and are therefore a little confused that it hasn't started yet. It's less than six months until the 31st March, after all. Be that as it may, we're all looking at our options. Some are considering teacher training, others opening a B&B, still others going over to the Dark Side (private sector consultancy). I am set on doing a Masters degree, and intend to bridge the gap between the end of my job and the start of a course with whatever work I can get, to keep me in rent and spaghetti. It seems clear that the longer I wait to go back to unversity, the more the cost will rise.

Everyone at work is reconsidering what they want from a career, what they enjoy, what they can afford, where they want their work-life balance to be. I'm very lucky to have no dependents or mortgage to support, and in any case would want to change jobs sooner or later in order to keep learning and climbing the ladder. It obviously concerns me how little work will be available before and after a Masters (during which I would rely on my savings, funding being non-existent). There just seems no point in worrying about it right now.

At the moment I'm young, well-educated, healthy, and living in an area of the country that's coped relatively well with the recession so far. Millions of people are going to be worse off when the cuts to tax credits, housing benefit, job seeker's allowance, and child benefit arrive. Never mind inflation on the rise, VAT rising to 20%, and public services being dismantled and sold off. When those millions start protesting, I'll be there too. Complete with a witty placard.

Tuesday, 26 October 2010

Roof Over Your Head

For context, I have a particular professional and personal interest in housing policy. Previous missives include:

What's Wrong with Private Rental

What's Wrong with Owner Occupation

What's Wrong with Social Housing

Why I Won't to be Able to Buy a Home in the next Decade

The Coalition Don't Get it and the Coalition really don't get it.

A lot of rumours swirled around prior to the spending review about massive cuts to the housing budget. How bad was it? Worse than that.

It remains unclear exactly how much funding for affordable housing has been cut, as it's funded by a confusing patchwork of programmes. Here are the numbers provided in the spending review.

From 2008-11 the government's National Affordable Housing programme had £8.4 billion of funding, with a target of 180,000 new affordable homes a year. (As a result of the credit crunch, I'm pretty sure this target will be missed.) The CSR allocates £4.5 billion to affordable housing over the next three years, with a target of delivering up to 150,000 over the spending review period. This includes existing commitments, and is therefore effectively a four year target. Consequently, the annual target for new affordable homes has gone from 60,000 to 37,500. Of course, high targets are meaningless if you can't meet them. But despite this, CLG's token Liberal Democrat minister Andrew Stunnell is claiming that the current government will provide more affordable housing than Labour did. Given that the budget for affordable housing has been halved and the target cut by more than a third, this claim looks nothing short of delusional. It's based on increasing rents for social housing, which provides homes for the disabled, retired, and vulnerable, whilst reducing housing benefit.

Whilst Mr. Stunell is being mentioned, I should comment on what appears to be his pet project: affordable housing in abandoned farm buildings. Sounds like a bad joke? Here is the 'Homes on the Farm' press release.

Presumably this policy is based on some idea of bucolic country life, or perhaps nostalgia for the feudal system. What it would amount to is isolating those unable to afford market housing from jobs, services, and transport networks. I find it particularly absurd that the press release emphasises young people. Speaking as a genuine young person, most of us live in cities because that's where we can find jobs. Moreover, urban areas offer actual services and leisure activities, as well as not requiring utter dependence on a car. I grew up in the countryside and, frankly, after going to university in a city returning to quiet rural life isn't very attractive. I'm sure some young people do want to live where they grew up, but treating barn conversions as some sort of panacea for rural housing problems is misguided. Quite apart from the fact that this policy isn't supported by any funding or legislation, being merely an exortation to farmers and local authorities.

Once again, this demonstrates the government's failure to look in any way systematically at housing, employment and poverty. I know I say this a lot, but these issues are highly interconnected.

Two brighter notes, though. Firstly, the shadow housing minister Alison Seabeck is horrified by the hatchet taken to spending on housing. Secondly, the cuts to welfare, including housing benefit, will need to go through parliament. There is still time for MPs to wake up and smell the unfairness.

Friday, 23 July 2010

Youthful high spirits

As a distraction from the scary labour market, I've been considering the housing market prospects for me and the rest of today's youth. This is akin to distracting yourself from an earthquake by setting off a small nuclear bomb.


I recently came across an article in the Independent's money section about a young woman called Eloise wanting to buy her own home. Eloise earns £22,350 and has savings of £1,000. She would like to buy a two bedroom flat in London, or maybe Bristol, and wants her financial decisions to be ethical, although I'm not quite sure what that means in this context.

I'm sorry Eloise, but I read this article and burst out laughing. SERIOUSLY? You really think that on those wages and with such paltry savings that you can afford to buy so much as a shed? Wake up and smell the coffee. In Cambridge, which is cheaper than London, I would need to earn £40,000 and have a £50,000 deposit in order to buy a two bedroom flat.


My generation, the twentisomethings renting at the moment and thinking it might be nice to buy one day - we are screwed.


We rent poor quality homes at at high cost, and are treated badly by rental agents and landlords because they can. They will continue to do so, and rents will rise with demand.

We struggle to save for the 25% deposits needed to buy a home. Low interest rates erode the value of our ISAs and our jobs look insecure, if we're lucky enough to find and keep one. Rates are expected to stay low for the next two years.

We attempt to repay our student loans, whilst glowering at our parents who got their degrees with no fees and generous grants. The interest rates of these loans are going up to 4.4% in September from the current 0%, and that's before the student loan company is privatised (as announced in the June budget).

We can't get social housing, because there isn't enough to go around and established families get precedence, reasonably enough. Funding for building more has been slashed and burned, and targets torn up.

We can't get mortgages, as we're seen as too much of a credit risk and don't have vast deposits. Introducing caps on mortgages has been suggested and returning to the era of easy mortgages would be highly unwise, given that unwise lending caused the downturn in the first place.

We can't find housing that fits our needs, because developers are building tiny rabbit hutch flats to store us in, and we're priced out of the few decent-sized houses that exist. UK new builds are the smallest Europe, reports the Commission for Achitecture and the Built Environment. Even the Daily Fail says so!

We simply can't afford to buy, as the gap between wages and property prices continues to gape wider and wider and youth unemployment rises inexorably.

I am not particularly happy about this, and doubt that anyone else in my demographic group is thrilled either. I certainly don't consider myself entitled to own a palace at the age of 25, but do think it reasonable to have a well-maintained home that I can feel secure in for more than six months.

The likely result of the coalition's so-called housing policy is this: the house price bubble will return in South, pushing up rents further. This is at a time when housing benefit has been capped and other benefits decoupled from housing cost inflation. Homelessness will increase. Mortgage availability, especially for first time buyers, is not about to get better. Employment prospects are poor and taxes rising. Last year, 75% of new housing starts had some form of government subsidy. Despite this, very low number of houses were actually delivered. With this support severely cut, the number of new houses built is already falling and will fall further. So prices will continue to rise, supply will continue to lag, ad nauseam, until the whole East of England falls into the sea in 2054.

Things aren't completely hopeless, though. Here are my suggestions for improving the state of the housing market.

  1. If the coalition aren't going to have a housing policy, they should get rid of the post of Housing Minister. This accords with their drive to get rid of bureaucratic non-jobs.

  2. Tenancy law needs to be reformed to make private rental more humane. Look how Germany and much of the rest of continental Europe manage it: longer tenancies, more rights for tenants to match their responsibilities, less of an assumption that home ownership must always take precedence. Implementing the recommendations of the Rugg Review would be a start.

  3. Second homes & buy-to-let should be penalised through the tax system, rather than supported. This may seem unfair to those just trying to invest for their retirement and so forth, but I believe it is necessary. It surely isn't justifiable to have millions of homes standing empty, when so many people are homeless, overcrowded, or housed unsafely.

  4. The planning system is in need of reform, as it cannot achieve what it needs to in the 21st century. However, reform needs to happen in a measured way with full consultation with actual planners, rather than abolishing bits at random and expecting Local Authorities to keep calm and bugger on somehow. (There will doubtless be a future post on planning and its current state of chaos.)

  5. The government needs to investigate and regulate oligopolistic behaviour in big developers and house-builders, including land-banking, with the aim of introducing a bit more competition into this sector. Other countries manage to build more and quicker, in part thanks to a much more dynamic and competitive building sector.

  6. It would be helpful to streamline compulsory purchase powers, which assist Local Authorities in building their own social housing by letting them grab unused land. The major cost of social development is the land, as the public sector is priced out by developers who can realistically expect 25%+ profit margins.

  7. The UK needs a culture change from the tired old adversarial planning system. I'm sure that more competition in the building sector would help with this. We might then be able to follow the Netherlands' good example and try public & private sector joint ventures to build new homes.

  8. Everyone needs to think differently about housing. A roof over your head is a right first and foremost, and an investment second. Likewise, we should stop thinking of a home as synonymous with ownership. If private rental was reformed and social housing more widely available, views should evolve accordingly.

  9. The planning system should make room for different kinds of homes as well as different tenures - canal boats, caravans, yurts, treehouses, old train carriages, hobbit holes, etc. Not everyone wants to live in a brick box, and it certainly isn't positive for the environment to force everyone to do so.


My current preference is for a yurt, after staying in one for a weekend's holiday. It would certainly cost quite a bit less than that elusive two bedroom flat.