Showing posts with label social housing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label social housing. Show all posts

Friday, 8 July 2011

On The Street

The government has a glorious vision that they will end rough sleeping, a praiseworthy aim that no-one can in good conscience take issue with. The Prime Minister, no less, states in the introduction to their new vision document that,

It is an affront to this country that last winter, one of the coldest on record, there were people still sleeping rough on our streets. While the temperature dropped below freezing, many were making do with doorways and cardboard boxes for beds. In a civilised society, this is totally unacceptable.


How right you are, Mr. Cameron! Moreover, he goes on to say that,

...tackling rough sleeping is not just about providing homes. It is about dealing with the wider causes of homelessness, from family breakdown and mental illness to drug addiction and alcoholism. This is a complex, multi-faceted problem.


Again, very true and reassuring to hear that at the highest level the government understand the complicated nature of the problem. If only this understanding was matched with some idea of the solutions. Set out in the vision document are six cross-departmental commitments to end homelessness. Before I get to them, here are seven actions the government is taking or has taken that are directly relevant to the number of people without homes. None of these are mentioned in the vision document:

  1. Radically altering the nature of social housing tenure. Currently mean weekly rent in the social rented sector is £75, less than half the private sector level of £156. The government is introducing a new tenure called 'affordable rent', which by default will be set at 80% of private rent (although theoretically there will be flexibility to set it lower). New and moving tenants will be presented with this exciting new tenure, plus existing tenants may be encouraged to switch. 'Affordable rent' tenancies will also be fixed term by default; currently social renting offers a tenancy for life or until the tenant no longer wants it. All this amounts to making social renting much more expensive and less secure.

  2. Cutting housing benefit in a number of ways (including capping, indexing to a measure of inflation that doesn't including housing costs, and calculating local housing allowance with reference to the cheapest 30% of properties rather than 50%), such that it won't be enough to cover either 'affordable rent' or private rent in many places. This is expected to reduce the government's spending on housing benefit by £1.8 billion. The Chartered Institute of Housing calculated that the changes could price private tenants on housing benefit out of, well, Britain.

  3. Weakening the duty on Local Authorities to help the homeless. Currently if you are homeless and ask your Local Authority for help, they can offer you private rented accommodation but you do not have to accept it. Under the Localism Bill proposals, if you did not accept the private rented option, the Local Authority wouldn't have to help you any further. The devil is in the detail here; how suitable does the offer need to be? What if it is too far from your job, or your child's school? Private rental is also insecure, with assured shorthold tenancies rarely lasting beyond 6 months, prone to volatile rent, and of poorer quality than other tenures.

  4. Cutting Local Authority funding, which impacts both on housing departments and on charities that rely on public sector grants, which form between them the front line of help for the homeless.

  5. Reforming the planning system through the Localism Bill, to remove regional housing targets and introduce confusing new ways of involving neighbourhoods (whatever they turn out to me). The Chief Executive of Taylor Wimpey, one of the UK's biggest house builders, said this of the proposals:

    ...can I tell you my great fear? In three years’ time, it all stops. We are operating currently on existing consent and on land banks. We need a flow of consent coming through the process to maintain and grow business. I fear that we will reach a point, in about three years’ time, when what we have currently on the stocks runs out, where in fact we have not got that supply coming through. That is the big challenge. That is the sort of transition [...] which so badly needs to be addressed.

    House builders obviously have a bit of a vested interest here, but he also has a good point. There is a shortage of housing in the UK and uncertainty about the planning system will only delay the building of anything.

  6. Cutting the National Affordable Homes Programme from £8.4 billion (2008-11) to £4.5 billion (2010-13, notice the overlap) and stating that it will only be spent on the new 'affordable rent' tenure. This housing will not meet the needs of the most vulnerable and impoverished people, by definition those who are most at risk of homelessness.

  7. Rejecting the conclusions of the Rugg Review, which called for regulation of the private rented section to deal with abusive landlords and substandard accommodation. The review proposed a light-touch system of regulation designed to stabilise the sector and encourage investment. The sector was supportive, but the government labelled it red tape and that was that.


As a result of this combination of policies, affordable housing will become scarcer, private renting remain insecure, social and private rents will rise, and housing benefit will reduce, whilst the Local Authority safety net weakens. The implications are worrying, and the Department of Communities and Local Government is well aware of it. The six-month-old letter recently leaked baldly states that just the changes to benefits will generate more than £270 million of additional costs to Local Authorities and cause 40,000 households to become homeless.

Wait a moment, didn't the Prime Minister say he really wanted to end rough sleeping? Let's look at the government's six commitments to do so.

  1. 'Helping people off the streets' by providing £20 million for a Homelessness Transition Fund. If that much money could end homelessness, surely there would be no-one sleeping rough at the moment. It will go to Homeless Link,a body representing organisations that work with the homeless and be spent on grants to pilot new ways of working.

  2. 'Helping people access healthcare' by, well, I can't really tell. The verbs used are 'highlight', 'support', and 'work with'. I've used such phraseology before and know what they equate to - very little. The government is trying to devolve healthcare commissioning to the local level, so how can they ensure the health needs of the homeless are fully met in every locality?

  3. 'Helping people into work' by using the Work Programme. However effective the new private-sector led approach might be, it will be impeded by the fact that there are currently 2.6 million more unskilled workers than jobs. If there aren't enough private sector jobs, what then?

  4. 'Reducing bureaucratic burdens' by reducing guidance and local authority reporting requirements. I genuinely don't understand how this will this tackle homelessness. Ironically, it might make it harder to calculate the level of homelessness nationally. Notably, there's also no mention in the report of how CLG will even monitor whether their pledge is being met.

  5. 'Increasing local control over investment in services' by analysing the costs of homelessness. That one just sounds like a non sequetur. Community-based budgets are also referenced, but it seems quite a heroic assumption that giving the community greater control over Local Authority money will automatically result in better services for the homeless. The government has also removed the ringfence on homelessness grant, leaving Local Authorities free to spend it on whatever their councillors might choose. Call me unduly cynical, but the homeless are not a big local election voting demographic. It's worthy of note that taking away the ringfence on the Supporting People budget (which also assists the vulnerable) has resulted in it being dramatically cut by many Local Authorities.

  6. 'Devolving responsibility for tackling homelessness' by giving the Mayor of London unspecified new responsibilities and £34 million to try and cushion the seismic impact benefit changes will have in London.


That final so-called commitment is the real key to this. The government has made a grand statement about ending rough sleeping, something that no government has managed even in times of economic growth and increasing public spending, then dumped the responsibility for actually doing it onto Local Authorities. Whilst making unprecedented cuts to their budgets. Nice work, Mr. Shapps. Is it really credible to presume the measures that form this vision will more-than-counterbalance the huge negative effects of other policies?

The above might give you the idea that I am doubtful that rough sleeping will cease to exist over the next four years. Meanwhile, the Mayor of London has pledged to end rough sleeping in the capital by 2012. According to figures from the charity Crisis, 3975 people slept rough at some point in London during 2010/11, an increase of 8 per cent on the previous year's total of 3673 and of more than a thousand since 2005/06. The cuts to housing benefit have yet to be implemented. Five and a half months to go, Boris. Good luck.

Actually ending rough sleeping would be a strikingly impressive thing to do. However the government's policies are already increasing homelessness, and by their own admission will continue to do so. Far from articulating ways to solve the problem, they are making it dramatically worse. Their whole vision for ending rough sleeping is thus just an empty promise and a waste of words. I can only hope that the members of parliament who signed their names to this incredibly hypocritical document are eventually held to account for it.

Friday, 4 February 2011

Return of the Localism Bill: What the Experts Say

The Localism Bill is currently stomping through parliamentary processes, Labour's attempt to derail it having failed. I recently found myself on theyworkforyou.com, an astoundingly useful website, reading transcripts of public bill committee discussions. This committee of MPs debates the Bill and calls representatives from relevant groups to talk about it. I came across some very revealing comments.

Chief Executive of the National Housing Federation on how the Localism Bill will change the supply of affordable housing:
Our assessment of what is likely to happen with this system, as we understand it, is that it will probably deliver new homes, but at intermediate rents. The overall stock of property available for letting at what we currently call social rent will significantly diminish—probably by between 125,000 and 130,000. There will, in fact, be a transfer away from social rent to higher intermediate rents.


Chief Executive of Shelter, on the effect the Localism Bill will have on the vulnerable:

Regarding the first part of the question about the impact on vulnerable groups—not just 16 and 17-year-olds—we think that the provisions to allow the discharge of homeless duty into the private rented sector will significantly threaten the stability that they might have. We will see a revolving door, with people constantly being in short-term lets in the private rented sector re-presenting as homeless. It does not give them a secure settled home and does not understand the nature of the problems they are facing. We would strongly contend that this is the wrong solution and that it will create significant difficulties in those areas.

On the private rented sector:
[...]
What this proposal lacks, if the Government wish to go down this route, is any licensing or regulation of the private rented sector. It will see a greater dispersal of very vulnerable people into the already least regulated sector. One of the Government’s first moves was to remove any agenda in the Rugg review or any desire to put more regulation into the private rented sector. That is a mistake.

And on private sector rents:
[...]
Let us be clear for a start: only 30% of the private rented sector in any one area will be available under the proposals because the Government have made it clear that that is the rate at which [Housing Benefit] will be paid. All those people who are being discharged will go into that—the bottom 30% in any one area. The Government are acting on the heroic assumption that landlords will put their rents down. We have seen no evidence from landlords or anyone else that rents will go down. Everything would suggest a marketplace with an increased demand and no increase in supply, where the prices will go up and up. We have pushed and pushed the Government on this, for their evidence as to what it suggests, and we have pushed the Department for Work and Pensions and the Ministers for the evidence, and they have shown us none. We are fearful that a lot of these assumptions are based on the misconception that rents will go down. It is a significant problem both for this Bill and the welfare Bill.


MD of Harrow Estates, a major national housebuilder, on planning:

The Bill provides for the abolition of regional spatial strategies, which is a high profile issue, and that removes one layer of the planning system. However, the Bill then introduces neighbourhood planning frameworks, so we are effectively removing one tier and replacing it with another. The number of hurdles that must be considered in order to navigate the planning process and deliver housing remains effectively the same. [...] The neighbourhood development plans can potentially introduce a plethora of issues, but at an extremely local and detailed level. The burden on the house building industry—the cost and investment of resources in order to deliver houses—potentially remains the same.


Chief Executive of Taylor Wimpey, another one of the UK's largest house-builders, on rent levels:
Having heard the tail end of the previous discussion about [private] rents falling, I would very much concur: I can’t see that happening at a point when the availability of capital is low and house prices are still relatively high. The only meaningful long-term solution involves a greater degree of housing supply, because that brings down the overall cost of housing, whether for private owners or the rented sector.

On when the housing industry will be able to build houses at 2007-8 levels, which it should be noted was still below the level of demand:

Without the Bill, with the status quo, it would probably be somewhere around six years before you saw the industry producing at the same level. With the Bill, I would estimate longer, because I think the transition will slow things down. Plucking a year out of thin air, that would be more like seven or eight years. It will make a difference to the speed of planning permissions, but it will be slow. It will not be slow because of the industry’s ability to build. It will be slow because of mortgage and planning permission availability.

[the other developers state that they agree with this view]

[...] can I tell you my great fear? In three years’ time, it all stops. We are operating currently on existing consent and on land banks. We need a flow of consents coming through the process to maintain and grow business. I fear that we will reach a point, in about three years’ time, when what we have currently on the stocks runs out, where in fact we have not got that supply coming through. That is the big challenge. That is the sort of transition [...] which so badly needs to be addressed.


President of the Planning Officers Society on the cost of Neighbourhood Plans:

[...] resources are a significant issue. What we have proposed in our response is that there should be some mechanism for councils, working with their communities, to resolve priorities. In my borough in London, for example, we have many very deprived wards, and we are already doing a lot of master-planning work with communities. It is not quite in this form [...]
Those are very expensive processes. They can take around 12 to 18 months. As well as using staff in the council—perhaps the equivalent of two full-time workers throughout the period—we have to employer master planners, urban designers, traffic consultants and the like. You are talking about £130,000 to £150,000 for a community of about 10,000. Even then, that is not a very detailed set of proposals for the whole place—one focuses on key issues. We have spent up to £250,000, or something of that order. These are places that need that master-planning work, not only because they are very deprived communities, which need to see change and investment, but because they are part of our growth area, so there is a wider benefit to creating more homes and more jobs for more people.

How does that sit as a priority alongside the neighbourhood planning proposals, which could come from other parts of the borough that we would not necessarily regard as having the same need?


Chief Planner for the Town and Country Planning Association on climate change:

The challenge [...] is what we are going to do with the major issues like climate change and renewable energy, and all sorts of forms of development that play out at a regional or national scale. My point is a tough one, and I do not really like to represent it because it is unpopular: will the sum total of 350 individual local authority decisions on carbon deliver the effective action we need on climate change—or on housing or on retail development?

On Neighbourhood Fora of the 'My House of Me & Two Housemates' type:

Planning suffers from a lack of legitimacy. The nightmare scenario is three people standing together as a neighbourhood forum in an urban area and taking on considerable powers. Looking at the detail of the schedules, I am conscious of two things: that local government, having once approved them, cannot dissolve them; and that as non-public bodies, none of the equalities duties would apply to them, the climate duty would not apply to them, and the sustainable development duty would not apply to them.


To conclude, an exchange between MPs.

Barbara Keeley, Labour MP:

I have a strong impression that this Bill was not ready. Parts of it have had very little consultation. In fact, I think that the community empowerment section has not had any scrutiny whatever; that was admitted in the note from the Department. To start with, as we have to spend our time on this for the next five weeks, I want to ask whether the Bill was not ready, and whether perhaps there has been a rush to get it out there. Is that why there are 126 order-making powers for the Secretary of State?

[...] in many of the sessions we have had this week, very negative concerns have been expressed about bringing chaos to the planning system, and getting to situation where we are not building the homes that we want and causing levels of homelessness. The difficult environment in communities and local government means that there are not the resources to do the necessary things. There are themes that have come across again and again in all the sessions. I had the impression sometimes that they were surprisingly negative and very strongly expressed by witnesses.

[...] there has not been enough scrutiny or consultation. Before I came here I was told that consultation was promised that never happened. Any Bill is poorer for that. There is no reason I can see to rush this Bill. If you are trying to make a profound cultural change, you need it to be accepted and not bridled at.


And the response from Robert Neil, Conservative MP and CLG Parliamentary Under Secretary of State:

[...] My judgment is that this Bill is in a good state of readiness.


Even though experts are saying very clearly that the Localism Bill would have massive unintended negative effects, I do not think the government is listening. The Housing Minister definitely isn't, as despite this bill determining the future of affordable housing, he is not even on the public bill committee.

Friday, 29 October 2010

The End is Nigh

This was not a cheerful way to start the working day:

Photobucket

On my desk I found the latest Inside Housing magazine announcing the death of social housing. The coalition's so-called reforms effectively end social renting as a tenure. Requiring new social tenants to pay 80% of market rents will result in one of two things:

Housing Benefit will have to increase to cover the much more expensive rents, increasing how much is spent on benefits in order to subsidise the provision of new social housing;

Or

Housing Benefit won't increase and will no longer be sufficient to cover social rents, ending the safety net for the vulnerable that social housing was meant to be.

I wonder which will happen? Here's a clue: the government is totally obsessed with reducing the housing benefit bill.

The National Housing Federation are saying that the level of new social rents will be so high that in places like Camden, Hackney and Haringey households would need to earn £54,000 to pay their social rent without housing benefit. David Cameron's defense of this is, '[Are] our constituents working hard to give benefits so people can live in homes they could not even dream of? I don't think that's fair.'

This welfare-scroungers rhetoric, seemingly taken straight from the Daily Mail, makes me incredibly angry. Cameron is ignoring the fact that the housing market is a disaster in this country, supply is inadequate, owned and rented housing is getting less and less affordable, and there is a particularly acute shortage of housing for the most vulnerable. That's why spending on housing benefit has increased. In London and the economically thriving parts of the South, private renting (let alone buying a house) is unaffordable for people on an average wage. It is a barefaced lie that only unemployed 'scroungers' need housing benefit and social housing. It is also a barefaced lie that social housing is in any way mansion-like.

Here are some facts from the government's own housing statistics.

  • The percentage of households who own their home outright and have no
    members of the household working (57%) is comparable to that for social
    renters. This is because both contain a high proportion of the retired.

  • 31% of social tenants are retired; only 21% are under 35. Younger people are far more likely to be in private rented accommodation.

  • Social housing is more likely to be overcrowded than private rented or owner-occupied. (6.7% of social renters, 5.4% of private renters and 1.6% of owner-occupiers are overcrowded.) A third of all overcrowded households live in London.

  • More than a quarter of all children in the social rented sector (25.7%) are living in overcrowded conditions, compared to 5.8% in the owner-occupied sector and 15% in the private rented sector.

  • More than a third of social renters work: 24% are in full time work, 10% in part time work. Only 8.4% are unemployed.

    Let me reiterate that: eight per cent of social tenants are unemployed. Would you like to see the table I got that number from? Here it is. David Cameron, your claims about unemployed scroungers are simply not true.

  • 24.5% of social tenants are economically inactive, meaning that they can't work and are not getting Job Seeker's Allowance. These would be the disabled, ill, and full-time carers.

  • Not all social renters receive housing benefit at the moment - 59% to be exact.

  • Households buying a house with a mortgage had an average income more than three times that of social renters (£47,500 and £14,800 per annum respectively). 65% social renters have incomes of less than £15,000 per year.


Does it seem like social renters are getting an unfairly good deal here? I think not.

Social housing is allocated to those that most need it - the elderly, disabled, young people who've run away from abusive families, homeless families with children. I'll tell you what's not fair, Cameron: dumping these people on the streets, shunting them between bed & breakfasts, or forcing them into overcrowded accommodation. You don't need me to tell you that this will trap people in poverty.

How can this government have the gall to use the word 'fair' as their mantra whilst callously kicking away the welfare safety net? They have decided that if you can't afford shelter you're just not trying hard enough, whether you're a child, disabled, ill, elderly, or just another victim of the recession. William Beveridge must be spinning in his grave.

Friday, 23 July 2010

Youthful high spirits

As a distraction from the scary labour market, I've been considering the housing market prospects for me and the rest of today's youth. This is akin to distracting yourself from an earthquake by setting off a small nuclear bomb.


I recently came across an article in the Independent's money section about a young woman called Eloise wanting to buy her own home. Eloise earns £22,350 and has savings of £1,000. She would like to buy a two bedroom flat in London, or maybe Bristol, and wants her financial decisions to be ethical, although I'm not quite sure what that means in this context.

I'm sorry Eloise, but I read this article and burst out laughing. SERIOUSLY? You really think that on those wages and with such paltry savings that you can afford to buy so much as a shed? Wake up and smell the coffee. In Cambridge, which is cheaper than London, I would need to earn £40,000 and have a £50,000 deposit in order to buy a two bedroom flat.


My generation, the twentisomethings renting at the moment and thinking it might be nice to buy one day - we are screwed.


We rent poor quality homes at at high cost, and are treated badly by rental agents and landlords because they can. They will continue to do so, and rents will rise with demand.

We struggle to save for the 25% deposits needed to buy a home. Low interest rates erode the value of our ISAs and our jobs look insecure, if we're lucky enough to find and keep one. Rates are expected to stay low for the next two years.

We attempt to repay our student loans, whilst glowering at our parents who got their degrees with no fees and generous grants. The interest rates of these loans are going up to 4.4% in September from the current 0%, and that's before the student loan company is privatised (as announced in the June budget).

We can't get social housing, because there isn't enough to go around and established families get precedence, reasonably enough. Funding for building more has been slashed and burned, and targets torn up.

We can't get mortgages, as we're seen as too much of a credit risk and don't have vast deposits. Introducing caps on mortgages has been suggested and returning to the era of easy mortgages would be highly unwise, given that unwise lending caused the downturn in the first place.

We can't find housing that fits our needs, because developers are building tiny rabbit hutch flats to store us in, and we're priced out of the few decent-sized houses that exist. UK new builds are the smallest Europe, reports the Commission for Achitecture and the Built Environment. Even the Daily Fail says so!

We simply can't afford to buy, as the gap between wages and property prices continues to gape wider and wider and youth unemployment rises inexorably.

I am not particularly happy about this, and doubt that anyone else in my demographic group is thrilled either. I certainly don't consider myself entitled to own a palace at the age of 25, but do think it reasonable to have a well-maintained home that I can feel secure in for more than six months.

The likely result of the coalition's so-called housing policy is this: the house price bubble will return in South, pushing up rents further. This is at a time when housing benefit has been capped and other benefits decoupled from housing cost inflation. Homelessness will increase. Mortgage availability, especially for first time buyers, is not about to get better. Employment prospects are poor and taxes rising. Last year, 75% of new housing starts had some form of government subsidy. Despite this, very low number of houses were actually delivered. With this support severely cut, the number of new houses built is already falling and will fall further. So prices will continue to rise, supply will continue to lag, ad nauseam, until the whole East of England falls into the sea in 2054.

Things aren't completely hopeless, though. Here are my suggestions for improving the state of the housing market.

  1. If the coalition aren't going to have a housing policy, they should get rid of the post of Housing Minister. This accords with their drive to get rid of bureaucratic non-jobs.

  2. Tenancy law needs to be reformed to make private rental more humane. Look how Germany and much of the rest of continental Europe manage it: longer tenancies, more rights for tenants to match their responsibilities, less of an assumption that home ownership must always take precedence. Implementing the recommendations of the Rugg Review would be a start.

  3. Second homes & buy-to-let should be penalised through the tax system, rather than supported. This may seem unfair to those just trying to invest for their retirement and so forth, but I believe it is necessary. It surely isn't justifiable to have millions of homes standing empty, when so many people are homeless, overcrowded, or housed unsafely.

  4. The planning system is in need of reform, as it cannot achieve what it needs to in the 21st century. However, reform needs to happen in a measured way with full consultation with actual planners, rather than abolishing bits at random and expecting Local Authorities to keep calm and bugger on somehow. (There will doubtless be a future post on planning and its current state of chaos.)

  5. The government needs to investigate and regulate oligopolistic behaviour in big developers and house-builders, including land-banking, with the aim of introducing a bit more competition into this sector. Other countries manage to build more and quicker, in part thanks to a much more dynamic and competitive building sector.

  6. It would be helpful to streamline compulsory purchase powers, which assist Local Authorities in building their own social housing by letting them grab unused land. The major cost of social development is the land, as the public sector is priced out by developers who can realistically expect 25%+ profit margins.

  7. The UK needs a culture change from the tired old adversarial planning system. I'm sure that more competition in the building sector would help with this. We might then be able to follow the Netherlands' good example and try public & private sector joint ventures to build new homes.

  8. Everyone needs to think differently about housing. A roof over your head is a right first and foremost, and an investment second. Likewise, we should stop thinking of a home as synonymous with ownership. If private rental was reformed and social housing more widely available, views should evolve accordingly.

  9. The planning system should make room for different kinds of homes as well as different tenures - canal boats, caravans, yurts, treehouses, old train carriages, hobbit holes, etc. Not everyone wants to live in a brick box, and it certainly isn't positive for the environment to force everyone to do so.


My current preference is for a yurt, after staying in one for a weekend's holiday. It would certainly cost quite a bit less than that elusive two bedroom flat.

Thursday, 15 July 2010

Sociable Homes

Social housing can be a rather emotive topic, and is strongly linked in many people's minds with feckless unemployment and teenage single mothers. For what its worth, this is what I know about it.


  • Social housing is not free; tenants pay rent. The level of rent is lower than in the private rental market, by approximately 50% in Cambridgeshire.

  • On average, social housing is of higher quality than private rented (see this post). It is also much more secure, as the landlord is not profit motivated.

  • Some social housing is managed directly by local councils, some by not-for-profit 'registered providers'. These are usually charities.

  • Thanks to the 1980s 'Right to Buy' policy, the level of social housing in the UK is far below that needed. The result is that many people in poverty are living in overcrowded, poor quality private rented accommodation supported by Housing Benefit. Right to Buy allowed many people to purchase a home, but also removed the better quality social housing stock.

  • Social housing is allocated on the basis of need, using a waiting list system. Anyone can be added to the list. In my area, those on the list then receive details of available properties and 'bid' for them if interested. The bidder judged to be in the greatest need gets the home. Levels of need are expressed in four bands, A to D, of which A is most acute.

  • On the 1st July 2010, Cambridge's waiting list had 6299 people on it, of which 147 were in band A. The total population of Cambridge is approximately 117,700 (including around 16,000 students). The most recent figure I can find for total social housing stock in Cambridge is 11,049 (2007-8). That same year turnover was 4%, which is typical. Once in social housing, tenants are understandably reluctant to leave.

  • In Cambridge and the surrounding districts, 40% of social renting households have at least one person in work. 11% are retired and another 11% unable to work due to ill-health or disability. A quarter are not seeking work; the majority of single parents understandably fall into this category.

  • The total number of people on waiting lists for social housing in England stands at 1,800,000, the longest the list has ever been.

  • Although some still call it 'council housing', councils haven't built social housing for decades. Recently there have been some efforts to get local authorities back into social housebuilding, but these have had very limited impact. For the most part, new social housing is provided through private housebuilding. Local councils have planning policies requiring developers to make a percentage of their housing 'affordable'. This definition includes but is not limited to social housing. As a result, when housebuilding slows down as it has on the back of the credit crunch, social housing is hit too. In Cambridge and its environs, the affordable housing target is 40%.

  • Central government supports and subsidises social housing through grants. When the credit crunch arrived, the then government introduced a range of new schemes to encourage housebuilding in general and social housing in particular. As a result, 75% of new housing starts in 2009 received some sort of public subsidy. Although it would be foolish to assume that none of them would have gone ahead without support, it's fair to say that most wouldn't. For all their faults, the Labour government put significant effort and money into social housing. Not enough, but significant amounts.


What changes is the Age of Austerity bringing?

The coalition are saying that there is no more money for affordable housing. Without government subsidy, social housing will not be built. Registered Providers could borrow money to build, except for the little problem that we're in a credit crunch. Loan availability for housebuilders is limited and not improving. Meanwhile, unemployment is increasing the number of households unable to afford to own or privately rent a home. There is already a shortage of social housing, and it will get worse.

The Department of Work and Pensions (DWP) are also mooting the idea of somehow encouraging jobless social tenants to move in order to find work. This seems to me an extraordinary misunderstanding of the nature of 21st century poverty. If I lived in a socially rented house, I wouldn't want to move to find work! Social housing is hugely difficult to get and extremely sought-after. Why would you want to move from such a preferable tenure into vastly more expensive private rental, with only the potential of a job as an incentive? If the DWP think that people will just be able to move from one social home to another in a more sought-after area, they clearly haven't seen the waiting list numbers recently. Nor have they seen that many social tenants either already work or cannot.

The problem at issue here is that economically successful areas of the UK have huge shortages of owned, rented and social housing. This has made them fundamentally unaffordable to live in unless you already have a reasonably-paid job. The DWP's tacit assumption is that people in social housing are choosing not to move to find work, because they are lazy, feckless, etc. There's no choice about it; the unemployed cannot afford to move. The government seems to think that social housing = appalling poverty ghetto. Not a helpful assumption.

Diane Abbot, the Labour leadership candidate, has written an excellent critique of this policy here. She picks up on the human cost - loss of social capital through splitting families and breaking up support networks.

Sorry, this is not the end of the woeful tale of housing. Still to consider is Housing Benefit reform, plus my suggestions for trying to fix this mess.

(Meanwhile at the Department of Communities and Local Government, regional targets for house-building have been abolished. Again. This has been announced at least four times now. How much more abolished can they get?)